By Lynn Venhaus
Get ready to groove! A harmonious blend of electrifying sound, smooth moves and soulful expression, “Ain’t Too Proud: The Life and Times of the Temptations” deftly delivered passionate personal portraits in The Muny’s premiere production.
The iconic songs that made this rhythm and blues group the most successful ever sound pure and powerful as the soaring falsettos, high tenor leads and deep bass notes recall a timeless soundtrack to the ‘60s and ‘70s – and freshly highlight their extraordinary career for those not as familiar.
This is an endearing classic jukebox musical with dramatic storytelling about perseverance, ambition, collaboration and resilience — how these five Detroit guys rose from humble beginnings to international stardom.
The show opened on Broadway Feb. 28, 2019, stopped for the pandemic shutdown on March 12, 2020, then resumed Oct. 16, 2021, and closed Jan. 16, 2022. It was nominated for 12 Tony Awards and won for choreography. National tours have stopped at the Fox Theatre in St. Louis twice, first in 2022, and then for a weekend in 2025.
The Temptations were the first Motown group to win a Grammy (“Cloud Nine” in 1969), had 53 hits in the Billboard Top 100, were inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame in 1989, and Billboard named them the #1 Greatest R&B/Hip-Hop Artist of All-Time in 2017.
Formed as The Elgins in 1961, founder Otis Williams (James T. Lane) assembled the first quintet to include tenor Elbridge “Al” Bryant (Robert Crenshaw), bass Melvin Franklin (Jawan M. Jackson), tenor Eddie Kendricks (Elijah Ahmad Lewis) and baritone Paul Williams (Daniel Yearwood).
Under Berry Gordy’s (Galen J. Williams) tutelage, they ascended the charts as The Temptations, with Smokey Robinson (Tyler Hardwick) first writing their hits. Bryant left in 1964 and was replaced by David Ruffin (Nick Rashad Burroughs), who sang lead on “My Girl,” “Ain’t Too Proud to Beg” and “I Wish It Would Rain.”
As they go through decades of fame, personal loss, and historical change, Norman Whitfield (Robert Crenshaw) took over as composer, writing bold songs about real-world issues, affected by the civil rights movement, Dr. Martin Luther King’s death in 1968, and subsequent Detroit riots.
The second member shift was when Dennis Edwards (Joseph Anthony Byrd) replaced Ruffin in 1968, then Kendricks and Paul Williams both left the group in 1971. Later members included Richard Street (Aramie Payton), Damon Harris (Tyler Hardwick), Glenn Leonard, Ron Tyson, and Ali-Ollie Woodson. By Williams’ account, there are 27 men who have been officially part of The Temptations, and today, there is an evolving roster.
This recognizable music instantly made a connection with the audience, and a comfortable rapport was established. A high-energy ensemble performed 31 Motown hits with synchronized, athletic dance steps.
Paul Williams, widely considered the group’s best dancer, helped develop those slick moves in the early days, including “The Temptation Walk,” which were recreated by Tony winner Sergio Trujillo, and then stylized by choreographer Rickey Tripp, making his dazzling Muny debut, aided by associate choreographer Nasha Harris Santiago
Also here for the first time, Music Director Darryl G. Ivey buoyantly conducted 23 top-tier musicians to masterfully blend those global smash hits. Under Marcia Milgrom Dodge’s fast-paced direction, pizzazzy sequences were enlivened by scenic designer Edward E. Haynes Jr.’s towering Ambassador Bridge set piece and Kevan Loney’s imersive video designs incorporating concert and television appearances. Rob Denton’s lighting design and Joshua Hummel’s sound design complimented the showbizzy atmosphere.
Costume designer Gail Baldoni based impeccable retro garments on the original designs by Paul Tazewell and included those stylish matching suits the guys were known for and sparkly gowns for The Supremes. Kelley Jordan fashioned the wigs, and the hairstyles grow in size as the 1960s progress..
Behind the flash, the actors conveyed a band of brothers – in the emotional highs and lows, and in the personal, professional and political struggles of their time. Dominique Morisseau’s book, while gritty, follows a conventional formula – but does not gloss over painful occurrences. The darker side includes alcoholism, drug addiction, domestic violence and suicide.
Morisseau adapted founder Otis Williams’ autobiography, written with Patricia Romanowski, for the basis of the musical, and he not only attended Monday’s performance, but spoke to the crowd after the curtain call. Williams, 84, still tours with the group.
As the sturdy narrator Williams, engaging James T. Lane broke the fourth wall. He also framed the heavy emotional cost of success, outliving his friends, and focused on keeping the band together. As the moral anchor, Williams dealt with the big egos and arguments, and is the last surviving member, so the story is his to tell.
Dynamic Nick Rashad Burroughs, such a live wire as James “Thunder” Early in 2024’s “Dreamgirls,” embodied the tempestuous and talented frontman Ruffin, who couldn’t overcome his demons.
A real aural delight is Jawan M. Jackson as the distinctive bass Franklin, nicknamed “Blue.” His “Papa Was a Rolling Stone” is unforgettable. No wonder that he originated the role on Broadway and is now part of The Temptations, for his rich, mature tone resonates so perfectly.
Elijah Ahmad Lewis, who was a principal standby on Broadway, plays the cool cat Eddie “Corn” Kendricks with verve, displaying the signature falsetto on “Just My Imagination,” “Get Ready” and “The Way You Do the Things You Do.”
Daniel Yearwood is a heart-tugging Paul Williams, providing warm, sincere vocals like “For Once in My Life,” and then emotionally going through a sad trajectory.
The polished and professional female squad played several notable roles, with Candice Marie Woods as a stunning Diana Ross, E.J. Hamilton as Mary Wilson and NaTonia Monét as Florence Ballard, all shimmering as The Supremes, with Monet also Tammi Terrell, and Nasia Thomas as Otis’ wife Josephine.
Noteworthy in support are Robert Crenshaw as Al Bryant and Norman Whitfield, two roles he played on the national tour and TJ Staten Jr. as Otis’ grown son Lamont. While his role as manager Shelly Berger isn’t as flamboyant as Uncle Fester, Cogsworth and Igor in previous Muny productions, it’s nice to see Steve Rosen return – and his curtain call schtick is very funny.
Besides the aforementioned, the hard-working ensemble included Joshua Keith, Essence Anisa Tyler, Riley Adams, AJ Bentley, Laila Fantroy, Kameron Henry, Myles Lacey, Kayla Montgomery and Landon Page.
We brought our fond memories to the Muny, and Dodge supplied the upbeat concert vibe to make it a lively and entertaining evening. She made the past feel very present.
A Detroit native, she played Motown 45s in her basement like my sister Julie and I did in our youth. So, of course we were seat dancing! And up on our feet for the curtain call. This is Dodge’s 11th musical at the Muny, and one that was deeply personal to her, which she conveyed to all of us there Tuesday night.
The music of The Temptations lives on forever, and the Muny audiences won’t soon forget the fun party atmosphere nor the quintet’s heartfelt journey.
The Muny presents “Ain’t Too Proud: The Life and Times of The Temptations” from July 27 to Aug. 2 on the outdoor stage in Forest Park nightly at 8:15 p.m. and is presented by Moneta. The runtime is 2 hours, 30 minutes with 15-minute intermission included.
Lynn (Zipfel) Venhaus has had a continuous byline in St. Louis metro region publications since 1978. She writes features and news for Belleville News-Democrat and contributes to St. Louis magazine and other publications.
She is a Rotten Tomatoes-approved film critic, currently reviews films for Webster-Kirkwood Times and KTRS Radio, covers entertainment for PopLifeSTL.com and co-hosts podcast PopLifeSTL.com…Presents.
She is a member of Critics Choice Association, where she serves on the women’s and marketing committees; Alliance of Women Film Journalists; and on the board of the St. Louis Film Critics Association. She is a founding and board member of the St. Louis Theater Circle.
She is retired from teaching journalism/media as an adjunct college instructor.
