By Lynn Venhaus

“Only connect” is a good motto to leave a theater with, where you just saw brilliance shine.

An abundance of new voices and fresh faces mixed with familiar stories and reliable veterans to give us another compelling year of theater among regional professional groups.

Sometimes, there were so many offerings, one couldn’t get to them opening weekend, or my schedule prevented me from early viewing. I attended around 80 eligible shows and am grateful for the theater companies accommodating me. This does not include touring, school or community theatre productions.

I am enriched and in awe of the talent in our midst. And sharing what it feels like to be human in the 21st century is a very wonderful experience. That sense of belonging and community abounds. Onward to a magical year ahead.

As a local theater critic and writer about arts and entertainment, here’s my highly personal annual assessments on 2024 output – my “LOTTIES” – Lynn’s Love of Theatre Awards, as I announce every year. They are not set at five, but categories vary. If I wanted to recognize a performer or a show, I did (my rules).

This is separate from the St. Louis Theater Circle, of which I am a founding member. My esteemed colleagues and I will present our annual awards at a gala ceremony, aka theater prom, on Monday, March 24, at the Loretto-Hilton Center on the Webster University campus. Nominations will be revealed soon.

“The Inheritance, Parts I and II.” Provided by Tesseract Theatre Company.

Production of the Year:
“The Inheritance, Parts I and II” by Tesseract Theatre Company

A 7-hour commitment but worth every minute, riveting from start to finish, with everyone giving their all. Epic in scope and intimate in execution, Tesseract Theatre Company’s production was exhilarating.

Playwright Matthew Lopez wrote a vivid and perceptive rich tapestry of yearning, desire, melancholy, fear, joy, hope, community, and love. Surprising in its wit and depth of feeling, this Tony and Olivier-Award winning play is a magnum opus on what it’s like to be gay in America.

Boldly directed by Stephen Peirick and seamlessly acted by a passionate ensemble, they each met their moments. Intertwining a sprawling cast of 13, Lopez examined healing, survival, what home means and a class divide, inspired by E.M. Forster’s 1910 novel “Howards End.”

It takes place decades after the AIDS epidemic while three generations of gay men grapple with those past tragedies, and the legacies of shame, secrets, and loss, especially at a time when hard-fought rights are available, yet shifting political tides make them vulnerable.

Because Forster examined class differences and hypocrisy in British society in the early 20th century, so does Lopez project his characters in the early 21st century.

In an uncommon structure, Lopez tackled the complexities we all face, connecting characters, ambitions and eras in a swirling, dizzying, fantastic way. It is specific to the LGBTQIA+ experience, but allies could relate.

Companies of the Year:
The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis (large) and Tesseract Theatre Company (small)

Danny Williams and Kate Bergstrom. Provided.

The Rep gets the honor, turning around the venerable institution in spectacular fashion after it was on the brink of not surviving in 2023. A change in direction and a rallying community – both faithful and skeptical – helped the reset. So did new Artistic Director Kate Bergstrom, a sunny collaborative charmer whose efforts have been nothing short of astounding, along with managing director Danny Williams, who came aboard in 2022.
Two absolute stunners – “Moby Dick” and “August: Osage County” helped restore the luster in early 2024 while The Studio returned with “The Roommate” and a new partnership with Stages St. Louis for the crowd-pleasing “Million Dollar Quartet Christmas” followed a classic “Dial M for Murder” to deliver on its promises. Enthusiasm and goodwill is palpable at every function.

At the Tesseract Theatre Company, Kevin Corpuz and Brittanie Gunn took over operations, and continued bold moves started by founder Taylor Gruenloh in 2010. “The Inheritance, Part 1 and 2” was a landmark achievement, they shifted to musicals for the summer new play festival, and then their ambitious production of “Anastasia: The Musicals” in the fall cemented the statement that they have arrived. Can’t wait to see what is ahead.

Alan Knoll

Artist of the Year:
Alan Knoll

Actor-Director Alan Knoll is such a St. Louis fixture that it would be easy to take him for granted, but we never ever do. He’s not one to phone it in, always finds an entry point for us, and continues to stretch his capabilities. Last year, he did some of his finest work yet – as flawed dads in “We All Fall Down” and “August: Osage County,” and as a loyal servant in “Life Is a Dream.”

He also directed the acclaimed drama “Red” for New Jewish Theatre, where he previously helmed “Brighton Beach Memoirs” and “Broadway Bound,” part of Neil Simon’s Eugene trilogy.

In a 40-plus year career, he estimates he has been in more than 150 productions. He has worked at the Black Rep, The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis, The Muny, St. Louis Actors’ Studio, Upstream Theater and Imaginary Theatre Company, and the defunct Insight Theater Company, Dramatic License Productions, HotCity Theatre, Muddy Waters Theatre Company and Theater Factory in St. Louis, and at Arrow Rock Lyceum Theatre, which is one of Missouri’s oldest professional regional theatres, and is about 160 miles from St. Louis.

With his name in the ensemble, you can be assured of a first-rate performance, and with him in the director’s seat, you know you are in for a thoughtful, insightful production.

Tom Ridgely. Photo by Kevin Roberts.

Producers of the Year

Tom Ridgely, Sr. Louis Shakespeare Festival

As the producing artistic director of the St. Louis Shakespeare Festival since 2018, Tom Ridgely has expanded offerings and community partnerships, and taken an innovative, collaborative approach to their mission. In 2024, he oversaw one of the freshest summer productions yet in Forest Park’s Shakespeare Glen – “As You Like It,” and their TourCo’s “The Tempest” broke attendance records in multiple city parks and outdoor venues. Their work in schools and with young artists is an important component as well. Under his leadership, the organization thrives on reinvention and keeps its audiences engaged. The Shakespeare in the Streets events are eagerly anticipated, and they always attempt new ground.

Andrew Kuhlman and Gayle Seay

Andrew Kuhlman and Gayle Seay, Stages St. Louis

Andrew Kuhlman is the homegrown element as executive producer, rose through the ranks, while Gayle Seay brings an astute experienced eye as artistic director at Stages St. Louis. With two seasons under their belt, they showed Stages St. Louis’ audiences that they were moving forward while not messing with the recipe for success that co-founders Jack Lane and the late Michael Hamilton focused on when they started the company in 1987. Andrew, who was mentored by both Jack and Michael, continues to build partnerships while Gayle, familiar with the Stages’ family as a longtime casting director, knows the right people to go to in mounting their shows. They’ve demonstrated that theirs is a strong match, and they build on recent successes. Last season’s “Steel Magnolias,” “Newsies” and “Ragtime” continued the legacy.

Touring Production of the Year: (tie) “The Cher Show,” The Broadway Series at Stifel, and “Jagged Little Pill” at The Fox.

Jacob Schmitt and Bryce Miller in “Trayf”

THE MVPs

(Must have excelled in two or more shows this year, not a rookie, and whose presence made a difference)

Rachel Bailey
Ann Hier Brown
Matthew Cox
Jerome (J Samuel) Davis
Isaiah DiLorenzo
Jayson Heil
Bryce Miller
Drew Mizell
Joel Moses
Dustin Petrillo
Ben Ritchie
Jacob Schmidt
Molly Wennstrom
Eric Dean White
Sarah Wilkinson

ONES TO WATCH
Ashwini Aurora
Cory Burke
Jade Cash
Tyson Cole
Rafael Da Costa
Dominic Di Ciccio
Andre Eslamian
Aaron Fischer
Nadja Kapetanovich
Gabriel Paul
Allison Sexton

Nicole Angeli and Joel Moses in “Lungs”

DYNAMIC DUOS /TRIOS

  1. Nicole Angeli and Joel Moses in “Lungs” (Albion Theatre)
  2. John Riddle and Jordan Donica in “Les Miserables” (The Muny)
  3. Christopher Harris and Dustin Petrillo in “Red” (New Jewish Theatre)
  4. Nancy Bell and Kelley Weber in “The Roommate” (The Rep)
  5. Jacob Schmidt and Bryce A. Miller in “Trayf” (New Jewish Theatre)
  6. Andre Navid Eslamian and Leta DeBardeleben in “Longing”
  7. Adrianna Jones, Amber Alexandria Rose and De-Rance Blaylock in “Blues in the Night” (The Black Rep)
  8. Cameron Jamarr Davis and Eileen Engel in “Dutchman” (Soul Siren Playhouse)
  9. Mitch Henry-Eagles and Molly Wennstrom in “First Date” (New Jewish Theatre)
  10. Kari Ely and Peter Mayer in “Cat on a Hot Tin Roof” (Tennessee Williams Festival St. Louis)
  11. Isaiah Henry and Bianca Sanborn in “As You Like It” (St Louis Shakespeare Festival)
  12. Rachel Tibbetts and Ellie Schwetye in “Romanov Family Yard Sale” (ERA)
  13. Hailey Medrano and Bridgette Bassa in “We All Fall Down” (New Jewish Theatre)
  14. Greg Hunsaker and Jane Paradise in “Love in the Time of Nothing,” LaBute New Play Festival.
  15. Matt Anderson, Jeremy Goldmeier, and Donna Parrone as Haunted House actors in “Ripcord” (Stray Dog Theatre)

BRINGING THE HOUSE DOWN

(Best Musical Numbers)

Tiffany Mann in the 2024 Muny production of “Dreamgirls.” Photo by Phillip Hamer
  1. Tiffany Mann as Effie singing “And I’m Telling You I’m Not Going” in “Dreamgirls,” The Muny
  2. Tamar Greene and Shereen Pimentel as Coalhouse Walker and Sarah singing “Wheels of a Dream” in “Ragtime,” Stages St. Louis
  3. John Riddle as Jean Valjean singing “Bring Him Home” in “Les Miserables,” The Muny
  4. Jessica Vosk as Jenna singing “She Used to be Mine” in “Waitress,” The Muny
  5. Shereen Pimentel as Sarah singing “Your Daddy’s Son” in “Ragtime,” Stages St. Louis
  6. Jordan Donica as Javert singing “Stars” and “Soliloquy” in “Les Miserables” at The Muny.
  7. Aaron Fischer as Dimitry singing “Everything to Win” in Anastasia,” Tesseract Theatre Company
  8. Katerina McCrimmon as Fanny Brice singing “Don’t Rain on My Parade” in “Funny Girl” at The Fox.
  9. The Women (Adrianna Jones, Amber Alexandria Rose and De-Rance Blaylock) singing “Take It Right Back” in “Blues in the Night,” The Black Rep.
  10. Matthew Cox as Crutchie singing “Letter from the Refuge” in “Newsies” at Stages St. Louis
  11. Jamaal Fields-Green as Michael Jackson in the “MJ – The Musical” finale in the touring production at The Fox. Whatever that ‘surprise’ move he concocted for the 1992 “Dangerous” World Tour was. One of the most exhilarating things I’ve ever seen in a musical.

BEST YOUTH PERFORMERS

  1. Will Schulte, “Les Miserables,” The Muny
  2. Zoe Klevorn, “Ragtime,” Stages St Louis
  3. Shane Rose, “All My Sons,” New Jewish Theatre
  4. Riley Carter Adams, “As You Like It,” St. Louis Shakespeare Festival
  5. Vivian Helena Himes, “Wedding Band,” The Black Repertory Theatre
  6. Lucy Miller, “Wedding Band,” The Black Repertory Theatre
  7. Davin Wade, “Newsies,” Stages St. Louis
  8. Maliah Strawbridge, “Big Machine,” Fly North Theatricals
  9. Ellie Schwartz (Shprintze) and Zoe Klevorn (Bielke) in “Fiddler on the Roof,” The Muny

BEST NEW PLAYS

Greg Hunsaker and Jane Paradise in “Love in the Time of Nothing” at the LaBute New Play Festival. Patrick Huber photo.

  1. “Longing” by Lize Lewy
  2. “Elephants’ Graveyard” by Marjorie Williamson, First Run Theatre
  3. “Love in the Time of Nothing” by Jayne Hannah, St. Louis Actors’ Studio, LaBute New Play Festival
  4. “Don’t Be a Hero, Thank You” by Katherine Leemon, Prison Performing Arts
  5. “Romanov Family Yard Sale” by Courtney Bailey, ERA
  6. “Wolf Kings” by Chuck Harper and Maggie Conroy, Young Liars
  7. “Am I Dangerous” by e.k. doolin, Contraband Theatre
  8. “Who’s on First” by Neil LaBute, St. Louis Actors’ Studio, LaBute New Play Festival
  9. “Cash Flow,” Marjorie Williamson, First Run Theatre
  10. “Sandra’s Son,” Cbabi Bayoc (work in progress)

As You Like It. Photo by Phillip Hamer.

BEST COMEDY PRODUCTIONS

  1. “As You Like It,” St. Louis Shakespeare Festival
  2. “Trayf,” New Jewish Theatre
  3. “The Roommate,” The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis
  4. “Woman in Mind (December Bee),” Albion Theatre
  5. “Steel Magnolias,” Stages St. Louis
  6. “Spirits to Enforce,” The Midnight Company
  7. “Life Upon the Wicked Stage,” Tennessee Williams Festival St. Louis
  8. “The Tempest,” St. Louis Shakespeare Festival, Tour Co.
  9.  “Romanov Family Yard Sale,” ERA
  10. “Red Jasper,” Michael Madden Productions

BEST DRAMA PRODUCTIONS

  1. “The Inheritance, Part 1 and 2,” Tesseract Theatre Company
  2. “Moby Dick,” The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis
  3. “All My Sons,” New Jewish Theatre
  4. “August: Osage County,” The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis
  5. “Red,” New Jewish Theatre
  6. “The Whale,” St. Louis Actors’ Studio
  7. “Cat on a Hot Tin Roof,” Tennessee Williams Festival St. Louis,
  8. “Life is a Dream,” Upstream Theater
  9. “Hold On!” The Black Rep
  10. “Dutchman,” Soul Siren Playhouse
Adrianna Hicks in “Anything Goes” at The Muny. Philip Hamer photo.

BEST MUSICAL PRODUCTIONS

  1. “Anything Goes,” The Muny
  2. “Ragtime,” Stages St. Louis
  3. “Fiddler on the Roof,” The Muny
  4. “Anastasia,” Tesseract Theatre Company
  5. “Newsies,” Stages St. Louis
  6. “First Date,” New Jewish Theatre
  7. “In the Heights,” The Muny
  8. “Blues in the Night, “The Black Rep
  9. “(Title of Show),” Prism Theatre
  10. “Waitress,” The Muny

BEST SUPPORTING ACTRESS IN A COMEDY

  1. Zoe Vonder Haar, “Steel Magnolias,” Stages St. Louis
  2. Michelle Hand, “As You Like It,” St. Louis Shakespeare Festival
  3. Kari Ely, “Steel Magnolias,” Stages St Louis
  4. Molly Wennstrom, “As You Like It,” St Louis Shakespeare Festival
  5. Susan Wylie, “Woman in Mind (December Bee),” Albion Theatre
  6. Jasmine Cheri Rush, “As You Like It,” St. Louis Shakespeare Festival
  7. Ricki Franklin, “As You Like It,” St. Louis Shakespeare Festival
  8. Anna Blair, “The Butcher of Baraboo,” West End Players Guild
  9. Liz Mischel, “Bell, Book & Candle,” Stray Dog Theatre
  10. Ami Loui, “Steel Magnolias,” Stages St. Louis
Emily Baker and Isaiah Di Lorenzo in “Woman in Mind (December Bee).” Albion Theatre.

BEST SUPPORTING ACTOR IN A COMEDY

  1. Spencer Sickmann, “Trayf,” New Jewish Theatre
  2. Chuck Winning, “Grief & Woe,” LaBute New Play Festival,
  3. Isaiah DiLorenzo, “Woman in Mind (December Bee),” Albion Theatre
  4. Joseph Garner, “Woman in Mind (December Bee),” Albion Theatre
  5. Cassidy Flynn, “Romanov Family Yard Sale,” ERA
  6. Danny Brown, “Woman in Mind (December Bee),” Albion Theatre

BEST ACTRESS IN A COMEDY

  1. Emily Baker, “Woman in Mind (December Bee),” Albion Theatre
  2. Caroline Amos, “As You Like It,” St. Louis Shakespeare Festival
  3. Kelley Weber, “The Roommate,” The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis
  4. LaWanda Jackson, “Don’t Be a Hero, Thank You,” Prison Performing Arts
  5. Nancy Nigh, “Red Jasper,” Michael Madden Productions
  6. Joy Christina Turner, “The Tempest,” St. Louis Shakespeare Festival
  7. Claire Coffey, “Bell, Book & Candle,” Stray Dog Theatre
  8. Gwynneth Rausch, “Elephants’ Graveyard,” First Run Theatre
  9. Jan Meyer, “Elephants’ Graveyard,” First Run Theatre
    10. (tie) Annie Baker, “Ripcord,” Stray Dog Theatre
  10.  (tie) Julie Layton, “Life Upon the Wicked Stage,” Tennessee Williams Festival St. Louis

BEST ACTOR IN A COMEDY

  1. Jacob Schmidt, “Trayf,” New Jewish Theatre
  2. Bryce A. Miller, “Trayf,” New Jewish Theatre
  3. Ben Ritchie “Red Jasper,” Michael Madden Productions
  4. Alan Knoll, “We All Fall Down,” New Jewish Theatre
  5. Joel Wilper, “Bell, Book & Candle,” Stray Dog Theatre
Denise Thimes and Alex Jay in “King Hedley II” at The Black Rep.

BEST SUPPORTING ACTRESS IN A DRAMA

  1. Nadja Kapetanovich, “The Whale,” St. Louis Actors’ Studio
  2. Claire Karpen, “August: Osage County,” The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis
  3. Alex Jay, “King Hedley II,” The Black Rep
  4. Evann De-Bose, “Hold On!” The Black Rep
  5. Kari Ely, “Cat on a Hot Tin Roof,” Tennessee Williams Festival St. Louis
  6. Denise Thimes, “King Hedley II,” The Black Rep
  7. Astrid Van Wieren, “August: Osage County,” The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis
  8. Margery Handy, “The Inheritance, Parts 1 and 2,” Tesseract Theatre Company
  9. Kristen Joy Lintvedt, “All My Sons,” New Jewish Theatre
  10. Kari Ely, “Wedding Band,” The Black Rep

BEST ACTRESS IN A DRAMA

  1. Maggie Wininger, “Molly Sweeney,” Albion Theatre
  2. Ellen McLaughlin, “August: Osage County,” The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis
  3. Amy Loui, “All My Sons,” New Jewish Theatre
  4. Nicole Angeli, “Lungs,” Albion Theatre
  5. Jacqueline Thompson, “Wedding Band,” The Black Repertory
  6. Eileen Engel, “Dutchman,” Soul Siren Playhouse
  7. Jennifer Theby-Quinn, “Life is a Dream,” Upstream Theater

BEST SUPPORTING ACTOR IN A DRAMA

  1. Alan Knoll, “August: Osage County,” The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis
  2. Jayson Heil, “All My Sons,” New Jewish Theatre
  3. Dustin Petrillo, “Red,” New Jewish Theatre
  4. Eric Dean White, “Hold On!” The Black Rep
  5. Jerome Davis, ‘King Hedley II,” The Black Rep
  6. Alex C. Moore, “The Inheritance, Parts I and 2,” Tesseract Theatre Company
  7. Michael James Reed, “August: Osage County,” The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis
  8. Tyson Cole, “The Inheritance, Parts I and 2,’ Tesseract Theatre Company
  9. Joseph Garner, “Dark Matters,” West End Players Guild
  10. Jerry Vogel, “Life is a Dream,” Upstream Theater
  11. Gary Glasgow, “Life is a Dream,” Upstream Theater
Greg Johnston and Jayson Heil in “All My Sons.” New Jewish Theatre.

BEST ACTOR IN A DRAMA

  1. Greg Johnston, “All My Sons,” New Jewish Theatre
  2. Christopher Harris, “Red,” New Jewish Theatre
  3. William Roth, “The Whale,” St. Louis Actos’ Studio
  4. Gabriel Paul, “The Inheritance, Parts 1 and 2,” Tesseract Theatre Company
  5. Joel Moses, “Lungs,” Albion Theatre
  6. Reginald Pierre, “Life is a Dream,” Upstream Theatre
  7. Andre Eslamian, “Longing”
  8. Enoch King, “Hold On!” The Black Rep
  9. Cameron Jamarr Davis, “Dutchman,” Soul Siren Playhouse

BEST SUPPORTING ACTRESS IN A MUSICAL

  1. Lissa De Guzman, “Waitress,” The Muny
  2. Nicole Michelle Haskins, “Waitress,” The Muny
  3. Sarajane Clark, “Ruthless,” Stray Dog Theatre
  4. Rachel Bailey, “Title of Show,” Prism Theatre Company
  5. Kimmie Kidd-Booker, “Anastasia: The Musical,” Tesseract Theatre Company
  6. Shereen Pimentel, “Ragtime,” Stages St. Louis
  7. Lauren Tenenbaum, “American Idiot,” New Line Theatre
  8. Emily Bautista, “Les Miserables,” The Muny
  9. Samantha Massell, “Fiddler on the Roof,” The Muny
  10. Nancy Ticotin, “In the Heights,” The Muny
  11. Adrianna Hicks “Anything Goes,” The Muny
Tamar Greene and Shereen Pimentel in “Ragtime” at Stages St. Louis. Phillip Hamer photo.

BEST SUPPORTING ACTOR IN A MUSICAL

  1. Matthew Cox, “Ragtime,” Stages St. Louis
  2. George Abud, “Anything Goes,” The Muny
  3. Matthew Cox, “Newsies,” Stages St Louis
  4. Fergie L. Philippe, “Disney’s The Little Mermaid,” The Muny
  5. Donald Kidd, “Anastasia: The Musical,” Tesseract Theatre Company
  6. James D. Gish, “Les Miserables,” The Muny
  7. Nick Rashad Burroughs, “Dreamgirls,” The Muny
  8. Aaron Kamphoefner, “Sweet Potato Queens,” New Line Theatre
  9. Kevin Chamberlin, “Anything Goes,” The Muny
  10. Will Bonfiglio, “First Date,” New Jewish Theatre
  11. Jayson Heil, “First Date,” New Jewish Theatre
  12. Troy Iwata, “Waitress,” The Muny
  13. Rafael DaCosta, “Dracula,” New Line Theatre

BEST ACTRESS IN A MUSICAL

  1. Jessica Vosk, “Waitress,” The Muny
  2. Tiffany Mann, “Dreamgirls,” The Muny
  3. Sarah Wilkinson, “Anastasia,” Tesseract Theatre Company
  4. Marissa McGowan, “Ragtime,” Stages St. Louis
  5. Sarah Gene Dowling, “Ruthless,” Stray Dog Theatre
  6. Jill Abramovitz, “Fiddler on the Roof,” The Muny
  7. Jaelyn Hawkins, “(title of show),” Prism Theatre
  8. Taylor Quick, “Newsies,” Stages St. Louis
  9. Katie Orr, “(title of show),” Prism Theatre
  10. Savy Jackson, “Disney’s The Little Mermaid,” The Muny
Jill Abramovitz and Adam Heller in the 2024 Muny production of “Fiddler on the Roof.” Photo by Phillip Hamer

BEST ACTOR IN A MUSICAL (Male or Non-binary)

  1. Adam Heller, “Fiddler on the Roof.” The Muny
  2. John Riddle, “Les Miserables,” The Muny
  3. Jordan Donica, “Les Miserables,” The Muny
  4. Aaron Fischer, “Anastasia,” Tesseract Theatre Company
  5. Tamar Greene, “Ragtime,” Stages St. Louis
  6. Benji Santiago, “In the Heights,” The Muny
  7. Drew Mizell, “Nevermore,” Stray Dog Theatre
  8. Jay Armstrong Johnson, “Anything Goes,” The Muny
  9. Al Bastin, “The Big Machine,” Fly North Theatricals
  10. Clayton Humburg, “American Idiot,” New Line Theatre

BEST ENSEMBLE IN A COMEDY

  1. “Romanov Family Yard Sale,” ERA
  2. “Spirits to Enforce,” Midnight Company
  3. “As You Like It, St. Louis,” Shakespeare Festival
  4. “Woman in Mind (December Bee),” Albion Theare
  5. “Red Jasper,” Michael Madden Productions
  6. “Life Upon the Wicked Stage,” Tennessee Williams Festival St. Louis
  7. “Ripcord, “Stray Dog Theatre
  8. “Steel Magnolias,” Stages St. Louis

BEST ENSEMBLE IN A DRAMA

  1. “The Inheritance, Parts I and 2,” Tesseract Theatre Company2.
  2. “August: Osage County,” The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis
  3. “All My Sons,” New Jewish Theatre
  4. “Hold On!” The Black Rep
  5. “Cat on a Hot Tin Roof,” Tennessee Williams Festival St. Louis
  6. “The Whale,” St. Louis Actors’ Studio
  7. “Moby Dick,” The Rep
  8. Life is a Dream,” Upstream Theatre
  9. “King Hedley II,” The Black Rep
  10. “Hamlet,” St Louis Shakespeare
“August: Osage County” at The Rep.

BEST ENSEMBLE IN A MUSICAL

  1. “Anything Goes,” The Muny
  2. “Ragtime,” Stages St. Louis
  3. “Fiddler on the Roof,” The Muny
  4. “Anastasia,” Tesseract Theatre Company
  5. “First Date,” New Jewish Theatre
  6. “In the Heights,” The Muny
  7. “Newsies,” Stages St. Louis
  8. “Les Miserables,” The Muny
  9. ‘(Title of Show),: Prism Theatre Company

BEST LIGHTING DESIGN IN A PLAY

  1. Jayson M. Lawshee, “Red,” New Jewish Theatre
  2.  Minjoo Kim, “Dial M for Murder,” The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis
  3. Sean Savoie, “Hold On!” The Black Rep
  4. William C. Kirkham, “Moby Dick,” The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis
  5. Denisse Chavez, “As You Like It,” St. Louis Shakespeare Festival
  6. Denisse Chavez, “All My Sons,” New Jewish Theatre
“The Little Mermaid” at the Muny. Photo by Philip Hamer.

BEST LIGHTING DESIGN IN A MUSICAL

  1. John Lasiter, “Fiddler on the Roof,” The Muny
  2. Rob Denton, “Anything Goes,” The Muny
  3. Sean Savoie, “Ragtime,” Stages St. Louis
  4. Jason Lyons, “Disney’s The Little Mermaid,” The Muny
  5. Tyler Duenow, “Nevermore,” Stray Dog Theatre
  6. Travis Richardson, “Blues in the Night,” The Black Rep
  7. Jason Lyons, “Les Miserables,” The Muny

BEST VISUAL PROJECTIONS/DESIGN
 1. Zachary Grimm, “Longing”
 2. Kylee Loera, “Anything Goes,” The Muny
 3. Katherine Freer, “Disney’s The Little Mermaid,” The Muny
 4. Zach Cohn, “Hold On!” The Black Rep
 5. Joe Taylor, “Romanov Family Yard Sale,” ERA
 6. Mike Tutaj, ‘Waitress,” The Muny

BEST SOUND DESIGN IN A PLAY
1. Rick Sims, “Moby Dick,” The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis
2. Zachary Grimm, “Longing”
3. Michael Musgrave-Perkins and Philip Boehm, “Don’t Wait for the Marlboro Man,” Upstream Theater
4. Chuck Harper, “Wolf Kings,” Young Liars
5. Kareem Deanes, “The Roommate,” The Rep
6. Amanda Werre, “All My Sons,” New Jewish Theatre
7. Amanda Were, “Dial M for Murder,” The Rep

BEST COSTUME DESIGN IN A PLAY

Romanov Family Yard Sale.” ERA.
  1. Carolyn “Sully” Ratke, “Moby Dick,” The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis
  2. Michele Friedman Siler, “Life Is a Dream,” Upstream Theater
  3. Colleen Michelson, “Bell, Book and Candle,” Stray Dog Theatre
  4. Teresa Doggett, “Life Upon the Wicked Stage,” Tennessee Williams Festival St. Louis
  5. Sam Hayes, The Tempest TourCo, Shakespeare Festival St. Louis
  6. Marcy Wiegert, “Romanov Family Yard Sale,” ERA.
  7. Dorothy Marshall Englis, “As You Like It,” St. Louis Shakespeare Festival

BEST COSTUME DESIGN IN A MUSICAL

  1. Leon Dobkowski, “Dreamgirls,” The Muny
  2. Sarah Gene Dowling, “Anastasia,” Tesseract Theatre Company
  3. Brad Musgrove, “Ragtime,” Stages St. Louis
  4. Tristan Raines, “Anything Goes,” The Muny
  5. Brad Musgrove, “Newsies,” Stages St. Louis
  6. Eileen Engel, “Big Machine,” Fly North Theatricals
  7. Sarah Gene Dowling, “Nevermore,” Stray Dog Theatre

BEST SCENIC DESIGN IN A COMEDY
1. Scott Neale, “As You Like It,” St. Louis Shakespeare Festival
2.  Kate Rance, “Steel Magnolias,” Stages St. Louis
3. Andrea Ball, “We All Fall Down,” New Jewish Theatre
4. Gary F. Bell, “Bell, Book & Candle,” Stray Dog Theatre
5. Robert Mark Morgan, “The Roommate,” The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis

“Red” at New Jewish Theatre.

BEST SCENIC DESIGN IN A DRAMA

1, Margery Spack and Peter Spack, “Red,” New Jewish Theatre
2. Margery Spack and Peter Spack, “Dial M for Murder,” The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis
3. C. Otis Sweezey, “All My Sons,” New Jewish Theatre
4. Courtney O’Neill, “Moby Dick,” The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis
5. Rob Corbett, “Elephants’ Graveyard,” First Run Theatre
6. Timothy Jones, “King Hedley II,” The Black Rep

BEST SCENIC DESIGN IN A MUSICAL

  1. Wilson Chin, “Waitress,” The Muny
  2. Ann Beyersdorfer, “Newsies,” Stages St. Louis
  3. Ann Beyersdorfer, “Disney’s The Little Mermaid,” The Muny
  4. Arnel Sancianco, “In the Heights,” The Muny
  5. Edward E. Haynes Jr., “Anything Goes,” The Muny
  6. Jamie Bullins, “Blues in the Night,” The Black Rep
  7. Adam Koch, “Million Dollar Quartet Christmas,” The Rep and Stages St. Louis
Alysia Velez and the company of the 2024 Muny production of “In the Heights.” Photo by Phillip Hamer

BEST CHOREOGRAPHY

  1. Jared Grimes, “Anything Goes,” The Muny
  2. Lindsay Joy Lancaster, “Newsies,” Stages St. Louis
  3. William Carlos Angulo, “In the Heights,” The Muny
  4. Sylvia Hernandez-DiStasi, “Moby Dick,” The Rep
  5. Mike Hodges, “Xanadu,” Stray Dog Theatre
  6. Michelle Sauer, “AnastasiaL The Musical,” Tesseract Theatre Company
  7. Lesia Kaye, “Dreamgirls,” The Muny
  8. Chelsie Johnston, “American Idiot,” New Line Theatre
  9. Parker Esse (original choreography by Jerome Robbins), “Fiddler on the Roof,” The Muny
    10. Patrick O’Neill, “Disney’s The Little Mermaid,” The Muny

BEST MUSICAL DIRECTOR

  1. James Moore, “Les Miserables,” The Muny
  2. Khalid McGee, “Blues in the Night,” Black Rep
  3. Roberto Sinha, “In the Heights,” The Muny
  4. Darryl Archibald, “Fiddler on the Roof,” The Muny
  5. E. Renee Gamez, “Ragtime,” Stages St. Louis
  6. Zach Neumann, “Anastasia,” Tesseract Theatre Company
  7. John Gerdes, “American Idiot,” New Line Theatre
  8. Mallory Golden, “Title of Show,” Prism Theatre Company
  9. Larry Pry, “First Date,” New Jewish Theatre
  10.  Dave Sonneborn, “Million Dollar Quartet Christmas,” The Rep and Stages

BEST DIRECTOR OF A COMEDY

  1. Nancy Bell, “As You Like It.” St. Louis Shakespeare Festival
  2. Aaron Sparks, “Trayf,” New Jewish Theatre
  3. Rebekah Scallet, “The Roommate,” The Rep
  4. Lucy Cashion, “Spirits to Enforce,” The Midnight Company
  5. Gary F. Bell, “Bell, Book and Candle,” Stray Dog Theatre
  6. Brian Hohlfeld, “Life Upon the Wicked Stage,” Tennessee Williams Festival St. Louis
“Hold On!” The Black Rep

BEST DIRECTOR OF A DRAMA

  1. Stephen Peirick, “The Inheritance, Parts I and 2,” Tesseract Theatre Company
  2. David Catlin, “Moby Dick,” The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis
  3. Alan Knoll, “Red,” New Jewish Theatre
  4. Gary Wayne Barker, “All My Sons,” New Jewish Theatre
  5. Annamaria Pileggi, “The Whale,” St. Louis Actors’ Studio
  6. Ron Himes, “Hold On!” The Black Rep
  7. Philip Boehm, “Life is a Dream,” Upstream Theater
  8. Ellie Schwetye, “Lungs,” Albion Theatre
  9. Kay Ailee Bush, “Longing,”
“Anastasia: The Musical” at Tesseract.

BEST DIRECTOR OF A MUSICAL

  1. Brittanie Gunn, “Anastasia,” Tesseract Theatre Company
  2. Marcia Milgrom Dodge, “Anything Goes,” The Muny
  3. Rob Ruggiero, “Fiddler on the Roof,” The Muny
  4. Sam Hayes, “(Title of Show),” Prism Theatre Company
  5. William Carlos Angulo, “In the Heights,” The Muny
  6. Lee Ann Mathews, “First Date,” New Jewish Theatre
  7. Deidre Goodwin, “Ragtime,” Stages St. Louis
  8. Lili-Anne Brown, “Waitress,” The Muny
  9. John Tartaglia, “Disney’s The Little Mermaid,” The Muny
  10. Justin Been, “Nevermore,” Stray Dog Theatre
From left: Cleavant Derricks, Jonah D. Winston, Nicole Michelle Haskins, Jessica Vosk and Lissa deGuzman in the 2024 Muny production of “Waitress.” Photo by Phillip Hamer

Or, Theater interrupted by life…or something like that. Awards and reflections on the year.

By Lynn Venhaus
Often times, the wise words of others are in a loop playing in my head.

“I want life to imitate art,” Carrie Fisher wrote in “Postcards from the Edge,” and I often share that same sentiment. Particularly in 2019, which will always be labeled an “annus horribilis” for personal reasons.

Although John Lennon is attributed to have said “Life is what happens to you while you’re busy making other plans,” he really just quoted it in one of his songs on “Double Fantasy.” That one I put in regular rotation.

When times were really rough last year, I thought of Courtney Love’s band Hole and their album cover “Live Through This,” which was made after Kurt Cobain died. I kept repeating that phrase over and over.

Now 65, I know all too well the ebbs and flows of life, but last year seemed unusually mired in the deep end. You see, without going into lengthy details, I lost my cherished oldest son in December 2018 and my only surviving brother, who was terminally ill, Labor Day weekend on his 57th birthday; my two sisters and I lost our other brother years ago. Life is filled with loss, and I made it through all the ‘firsts’ with a lot of help from my friends and family. But pain, anguish and sorrow were/are unfathomable and the tsunami of grief is as unpredictable as anything in life.

My brother honored as a Legacy Coach at his alma mater, Belleville West, in January, eight months before his death. You can’t see his walker. He was a coach and junior high science teacher for 35 years.

As Matt went steadily downhill last summer, I decided I would spend more time with him, and I was already cooking his meals. So that meant missing some theater, and I have no regrets on that decision.

We all must prioritize what’s important in our lives. Theater has always brought me great joy and illuminated life in an exhilarating way, and last year, sometimes it was a lifeline.

I am grateful for the opportunities to see so much worthwhile theater, and I appreciate the theater community for being so understanding and patient last year on my circumstances and my crazy work schedule.

The upside to tragedy is the outpouring of kindness and concern from people – it was a comforting blanket I wrapped myself in, and was able to get up and get going because I knew I wasn’t alone, and that there were so many others to lean on and raise me up.

I can’t thank people enough and I am forever grateful – it means so much. Now, back to work. Words matter – I’m a writer, after all. A few years ago, as I was dropping Tim off at Union Station to visit some out-of-town friends after a break-up blindsided him, I mentioned ye olde chestnut about using what you learn at a later time, and he replied: “Like you say, Mom, everything’s copy.” I learned that from Nora Ephron. And it’s true.

Tim

Well maybe some day. Right now, I prefer to immerse myself in other’s words. Seeing how people take fresh pages of a script, how eloquent it can be, how well it can be interpreted – that is the task of the creative souls. And it’s so fun to see what can be crafted on a stage in town, whether it’s a small black box or the immense Muny stage.

Sitting in the dark, sharing a moment – that’s what it’s all about, and we sure shared some  outstanding moments in 2019. The eternal optimist, I am looking forward to another exciting year.

And as we all know, there will be more times we’re knocked down. And being helped up is one of the best things in life. And when you open yourself up — be it in conversation, writing or on stage, you feel human and whole.

How art enriches us is truly inspiring. 2019 was a good year for theater, particularly dramas, which were often inspired. It was important to have somewhere to go and something else to think about, as I continue to marvel at the accomplishments – passionate people behind their visions, strong talent and a desire to do good work, that it is about the work.

I like when people take risks, when they present new ways of doing things, and don’t rely on the same-old casting. My biggest pet peeves are miscasting and lack of character development/prep work/vision. If you are going to invest the time and want people to give up their time and money, then do the work, go above and beyond, and not just slide by. Hire who is right for the part, not just because they are a friend.

OK, off my soapbox.

I have now launched my longtime-coming website, and we should be full speed ahead in 2020, www.PopLifeSTL.com. I haven’t launched its daily and weekly features yet, but reviews and news releases are up. All in due time.

So, my awards this year are based on the 79 regional professional plays I did see, and not the touring shows nor community theater. That would add about 16 more shows. There is no way to see everything.

This is the year I gave up reviewing opera and let another reviewer go in my place. I needed to make some changes, and sadly, that had to be dropped. Maybe another work. I have been in awe of what Opera Theatre of St. Louis, Union Avenue Opera and Winter Opera achieve year after year.

My brother’s memorial service was the weekend of Shakespeare in the Streets, so I had to cancel, and he died the weekend I had RSVP’d for “The 39 Steps.” I saw “The Night of the Iguana” but left the next day to spend Mother’s Day with my youngest son in New York City, so missed “A Lovely Sunday Afternoon for Creve Coeur” and the other programming. I was on my way to the final matinee of “Death Tax” when an accident closed three lanes of I-64. Life…


I also traveled quite a bit this year, some for work, some for play. Tim was working on his MFA in screenwriting at DePaul University at the time of his death. He was home on holiday break. His professors named an award for him at their annual film festival, so I went up to Chicago the first weekend in June to see it happen.

However, I was fortunate to spend Mother’s Day watching Jeff Daniels as Atticus Finch in “To Kill a Mockingbird” in the sold-out acclaimed Bartlett Sher-Aaron Sorkin production in the Shubert Theatre. You could have heard a pin drop and the standing ovation was immediate, loud and long. Meeting the star afterwards was an unexpected thrill.

“To Kill a Mockingbird” brilliant production at the Shubert. Photo Credit: Julieta Cervantes

The week I was in NYC I also saw the  fabulous and fun “The Prom,” which was produced by local folks and had a book and lyrics by Centralia’s own Chad Beguelin, who I had the good fortune to meet in 2010 and have been writing about his triumphs ever since.

I did something new, too — I revised my late son’s last script, a comedy short that his DePaul professor raved about, A for the trimester. And we had a team shoot it in late September over a weekend, a real challenge and labor of love. As Eleanor Roosevelt said: “You must do the thing you think that you cannot do.”

Unfortunate, but sadly not considered in voting here: “The Revolutionists” and “Shakespeare in Love” at Insight; “Equivocation,” “Exit, Pursued by a Bear” and “Cricket on a Hearth” at West End Players Guild; “Such Sweet Thunder,” Shakespeare Festival St. Louis; “Nina Simone: Four Women” and “Milk Like Sugar,” The Black Rep; Black Mirror Theatre’s “Translations”; ERA’s “Never Let Go”; “Salt, Root and Roe,” Upstream Theatre; “Karmatic” TLT Productions; “The Merchant of Venice” and “The 39 Steps” at St. Louis Shakespeare; “Leaving Iowa” and “Travels with My Aunt” at Act Inc.; “The Hundred Dresses” at Metro Theatre Company; “Disenchanted” at Stray Dog, the parodies of “Jaws” and ‘Gremlins,” and the second leg of the LaBute New Play Festival at St. Louis Actors’ Studio.

Without further ado, I present my annual “LOTTIES,” which is Lynn’s Love of Theatre Awards, for 2019. These are my opinions alone. As in previous years, I usually name 10 my lists, but this year because of missing what I did, it’s either 8 or 9. Eventually, I will post my other ones, since 2014, in archives. And I intend to archive all the Circle Awards/Nominations for reference.

If you are wondering about the St. Louis Theater Circle Awards nominations, they will be announced on KWMU around noon on Friday, Feb. 7, with the press releases embargoed until 1 p.m. You can see the nominations here on PopLifeSTL.com in the afternoon.

I did not want my awards to coincide with the Circle, but it was not to be this year. However, these are my traditional annual awards, reflect my personal take on the year that was.

I am a Circle founding member; we began in 2012. The awards will be presented on Monday, March 30, at the Loretto Hilton Center on the campus of Webster University, (the Repertory Theatre of St. Louis’ home). More information will be forthcoming.

The 2019 LOTTIES* (LYNN’S LOVE OF THEATER AWARDS)

Barrett Foa and Meredith Baxter in “Angels in America, Part 2: Perestroika”

PRODUCTION OF THE YEAR: “Angels in America, Parts I and 2.”

Talk about ambitious. But oh, so worthwhile. The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis’ first show under new artistic director Hana Sharif was an absolute stunning visceral and artistic work and raised the bar. Not only did it take risks but its heavyweight cast delivered on its promise.

“Part I: Millennium Approaches” and Part 2: Perestroika” required a commitment of time but the investment was worth it. How interesting, too that a 30 year old play could be so relevant today.

“Brighton Beach Memoirs” became New Jewish Theatre’s biggest hit of all-time

COMPANY OF THE YEAR: New Jewish Theatre.

From start to finish, 2019 was a banner year for NJT under new artistic director Edward Coffield. “District Merchants,” “Time Stands Still,” “I Now Pronounce,” “Brighton Beach Memoirs” and “Fully Committed” were extremely well done with outstanding casts and production values.

Ellie in “Antigone: Requiem for Patriarchus”

ARTIST OF THE YEAR: Ellie Schwetye.

Ellie in “A Lovely Sunday for Creve Coeur”

One of the most versatile and accomplished women in town, she’s been honored and nominated by the St. Louis Theater Circle year in and year out. But this year might be her finest – and perhaps busiest – on record. She directed “Photograph 51” at West End Players Guild, “A Model for Matisse” for the Midnight Company and “Fully Committed” at New Jewish Theatre. She acted in “Classic Mystery Game” and “Antigone: Requiem for Patriarchus” at SATE. She did sound for “The Night of the Iguana” at the Tennessee Williams Festival and “The Women of Lockerbie” at SATE. She was involved in SIUE’s Summer Play Festival, with “As You Like It.” Her choices of music for any show are impeccable.
I’m likely missing a few things too.
She’s always excelled at being a collaborator but she deserves an award all it’s own.

The national tour of “Dear Evan Hansen” came to the Fox.

BEST TOURING SHOWS: “Come from Away” and “Dear Evan Hansen,” both at the Fox.

Repertory Theatre of St. Louis’ production of “Nonsense and Beauty” as the Loretto-Hilton Center. ©Photo by Jerry Naunheim Jr.

BEST NEW PLAYS:
1. “Nonsense and Beauty,” Scott C. Sickles, The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis
2. “Canfield Drive,” Kristen Adele Calhoun and Michael Thomas Walker, The Black Rep
3. “It’s a Wonderful Life,” John Wolbers, Metro Theatre Company
4. “Feeding Beatrice,” Kristen Greenidge, The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis
5. (tie) “Kim Jong Rosemary,” Carter Lewis, LaBute New Play Festival, St. Louis Actors’ Studio
5. (tie) “A Model for Matisse,” Barbara F. Freed and Joe Hanrahan, The Midnight Company

Caleb Miofsky in “Cry-Baby” at New Line

FIVE TO WATCH:
Summer Baer
Tristan Davis
Caleb Miofsky
Tateonna Thompson
Jordan Wolk

Alicen Moser in “District Merchants”
Alicen Moser in “Antigone”

12 ACTING MVPS
(For their noteworthy range of work in 2019, and not only St. Louis professional in some cases)
Nicole Angeli
Will Bonfiglio
Kevin Corpuz
Eileen Engel
Wendy Greenwood
Stephen Henley
Keating
Ryan Lawson-Maeske
Stephanie Merritt
Alicen Moser
Spencer Sickmann
Jennifer Theby-Quinn

DYNAMIC DUOS

J. Samuel Davis and Gary Wayne Barker in “District Merchants”
Will Bonfiglio and John Wolbers
  1. Gary Wayne Barker and J. Samuel Davis, “District Merchants,” New Jewish Theatre
  2. Jacob Flekier and Spencer Kruse, “Brighton Beach Memoirs,” New Jewish Theatre
  3. Will Bonfiglio and John Wolbers, “Photograph 51”
  4. Eli Mayer and Khailah Johnson, “Footloose,” The Muny
  5. Kevin O’Brien and Sara Rae Womack, “Guys and Dolls,” Stray Dog Theatre
  6.  Ryan Lawson-Maeske and William Roth, “A Life in the Theatre”
  7. Joe Hanrahan and Shane Signorino, “Popcorn Falls,” Midnight Company
  8. Erin Kelley and J. Samuel Davis, “The Agitators,” Upstream Theatre
  9. Jeffrey Heyenga and Robbie Simpson, “Nonsense and Beauty,” The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis
  10. Joe Hanrahan and Rachel Hanks, “A Model for Matisse,” Midnight Company

JUVENILE PERFORMANCE AWARDS

Flower girls in “I Now Pronounce” at New Jewish Theatre
  1. Millie Edelman, Abby Goldstein and Lydia Mae Foss as the flower girls, “I Now Pronounce,” New Jewish Theatre
  2. Leo Taghert as 10 year old Tommy in “The Who’s Tommy,” Stray Dog Theatre

 SPECIAL TECHNICAL ACHIEVEMENT: Michael B. Perkins for his exquisite video projection design in “Love, Linda” and “A Model for Matisse.”

Jane Paradise in “Brighton Beach Memoirs”

COMEDY AWARDS
Best Actress in a Comedy

  1. Jane Paradise, “Brighton Beach Memoirs,” New Jewish Theatre
  2. Laura Sohn, “Love’s Labors Lost,” Shakespeare Festival St. Louis
  3. Kea Trevett, “Love’s Labors Lost,” Shakespeare Festival St. Louis
  4. Susie Lawrence, “Sylvia,” Stray Dog Theatre
  5. Keating, “Well,” Mustard Seed Theatre
  6. Sofia Lidia, “The MotherF**cker with the Hat,” R-S Theatrics
  7. Perri Gaffney, “The Lifespan of a Fact,” The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis
  8. Colleen Backer, “Color Timer,” LaBute New Play Festival, St. Louis Actors’ Studio
Frankie Ferrari and Delaney Piggins in ‘I Now Pronounce”

Best Supporting Actress in a Comedy

  1. Laurie McConnell, “Brighton Beach Memoirs.” New Jewish Theatre
  2. Melissa Harlow, “Sylvia,” Stray Dog
  3. Frankie Ferrari, “I Now Pronounce,” New Jewish Theatre
  4. Delaney Piggins, “I Now Pronounce,” New Jewish Theatre
  5. Lori Adams, “Well,” Mustard Seed Theatre
  6. Ka-Ling Cheung, “The Play That Goes Wrong,” The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis
  7. Michelle Hand, “Pride and Prejudice,” The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis
  8. Taleesha Caturah, “The MotherF**with the Hat,” R-S Theatrics
  9. Caitlin Mickey, “Wittenberg,” Upstream Theatre
Will Bonfiglio in “Fully COmmitted” at New Jewish

Best Actor in a Comedy

  1. Will Bonfiglio, “Fully Committed,” New Jewish Theatre
  2. Isaiah DiLorenzo, “True West,” St. Louis Actors’ Studio
  3. Jacob Flekier, “Brighton Beach Memoirs,” New Jewish Theatre
  4. Steve Isom, “Wittenberg,” Upstream Theatre
  5. Michael Cassidy Flynn, “Classic Mystery Game,” SATE
  6. Adam Flores, “The MotherF**ker with the Hat,” R-S Theatrics
  7. Griffin Osborne, “The Lifespan of a Fact,” The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis
  8. Alan Knoll, “Wittenberg,” Upstream Theatre
  9. Joe Hanrahan, “Charlie Johnson Reads All of Proust,” Midnight Company
Spencer Kruse and Jacob Flekier in “Brighton Beach Memoirs”

Best Supporting Actor in a Comedy

1. Spencer Kruse, “Brighton Beach Memoirs,” New Jewish Theatre
2. Patrick Blindauer, “Love’s Labors Lost,” Shakespeare Festival St. Louis
3. Shane Signorino, “Popcorn Falls,” Midnight Company
4. Aaron Dodd, “The Motherf**ker with the Hat,” R-S Theatrics
5. Jesse Munoz, The Motherf**ker with the Hat, R-S Theatrics
6. Michael McGloin, “The Play That Goes Wrong,” The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis
7. Chuck Brinkley, “Brighton Beach Memoirs,’ New Jewish Theatre
8. Michael James Reed, “Pride and Prejudice,” The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis

“The Play That Goes Wrong” at The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis

Best Director of a Comedy

  1. Alan Knoll, “Brighton Beach Memoirs,” New Jewish Theatre
  2. Tom Ridgely, “Love’s Labors Lost,” Shakespeare Festival St. Louis
  3. Melissa Rain Anderson, “The Play That Goes Wrong,” The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis
  4. Ellie Schwetye, “Fully Committed,” New Jewish Theatre
  5. William Whitaker, “True West,” St. Louis Actors Studio
  6. Meredith McDonough, “The Lifespan of a Fact,” The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis
  7. Philip Boehm, “Wittenberg,” Upstream Theatre
“It’s a Wonderful Life” at Metro Theatre Company

Best Ensemble in a Comedy

  1. The Play That Goes Wrong, The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis
  2. Brighton Beach Memoirs, New Jewish Theatre
  3. Love’s Labors Lost, Shakespeare Festival St. Louis
  4. It’s a Wonderful Life, Metro Theatre Company
  5. (tie) The MotherF**ker with the Hat, R-S Theatrics

(tie) Well, Mustard Seed Theatre

BEST COMEDY PRODUCTION

“True West” at St. Louis Actors’ Studio
  1. Brighton Beach Memoirs, New Jewish Theatre
  2. Love’s Labors Lost, Shakespeare Festival St. Louis
  3. The Play That Goes Wrong, The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis
  4. True West, St. Louis Actors’ Studio
  5. Wittenberg,  Upstream Theatre
    6. Fully Committed, New Jewish Theatre

DRAMA AWARDS

Ben Ritchie and Nicole Angeli in “Photograph 51”

Best Actress in a Drama

  1. Nicole Angeli, “Photograph 51,” West End Players Guild
  2. Wendy Greenwood, “Time Stands Still,” New Jewish Theatre
  3. Jeanne Paulsen, “Alabama Story,” The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis
  4. Kristen Adele Calhoun, “Canfield Drive,” The Black Rep
  5. Zoe Farmingdale, “Indecent,” Max and Louie Productions
  6. Julie Layton, “Fifty Words,” St. Louis Actors’ Studio
Nisi Sturgis in “The Night of the Iguana”

Best Supporting Actress in a Drama

1. Nisi Sturgis, “The Night of the Iguana,” Tennessee Williams Festival St. Louis
2. Eileen Engel, “Time Stands Still,” New Jewish Theatre
3. Rae Davis, “District Merchants,” New Jewish Theatre
4. Donna Weinsting, “Nonsense and Beauty,” The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis
5. Rachel Hanks, “A Model for Matisse,” Midnight Company
6. Sophia Brown, “Fefu and Her Friends,” Theatre Nuevo
7. Miranda Jagels-Felix, “Antigone: Requiem for Patriarchus,” SATE

Jim Butz in “The Night of the Iguana”

Best Actor in a Drama
1. James Andrew Butz, “The Night of the Iguana,” Tennessee Williams Festival St. Louis
2. Barrett Foa, “Angels in America,” The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis
3. Gary Wayne Barker, “District Merchants,” New Jewish Theatre
4. Graham Emmons, “The Crucible,” Stray Dog Theatre.
5. Spencer Sickmann, “Farragut North,” St. Louis Actors’ Studio
6. Jim Poulos, “Oslo,” The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis

David Ryan Smith and Peter Fre

Best Supporting Actor in a Drama

  1. J. Samuel Davis, “District Merchants,” New Jewish Theatre
  2. Carl Howell, “Alabama Story,” The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis
  3. David Wassilak, “Farragut North,” St. Louis Actors’ Studio
  4. Karl Hawkins, “District Merchants,” New Jewish Theatre
  5. David Ryan Smith, “Angels in America,” The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis
  6. Ryan Lawson-Maeske, “Photograph 51,” West End Players Guild
  7. John Feltch, “Nonsense and Beauty,” The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis
  8. Gerry Love, “The Crucible,” Stray Dog Theatre
  9. Ben Ritchie, “The Crucible,” Stray Dog Theatre
  10. Ben Cherry, “Angels in America,” The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis
    (tie) Peter Freschette, “Angels in America,” The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis
    (tie) Taylor Gruenloh, “Two Degrees,” Tesseract Theatre
Angels in America

Best Director of a Drama

1. Joanne Gordon, “Indecent,” Max and Louie Productions
2. Anthony Speciale, “Angels in America,” The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis
3. Jacqueline Thompson, “District Merchants,” New Jewish Theatre
4. Gary F. Bell, “The Crucible,” Stray Dog Theatre
5. Ellie Schwetye, “Photograph 51,” West End Players Guild
6. Lucy Cashion, “Antigone: Requiem for Patriarchus,” ERA/SATE
7. Steve Woolf, “Oslo,” The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis
8. Seth Gordon, “Nonsense and Beauty,” The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis

Best Ensemble in a Drama Production

“Antigone: Reqiuem for Patriarchus” at SATE
  1. Angels in America, Parts 1 and 2, The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis
  2. District Merchants, New Jewish Theatre
  3. Photograph 51, West End Players Guild
  4. Indecent, Max and Louie Productions
  5. Antigone: Requiem for Patriarchus, ERA and SATE
  6. The Crucible, Stray Dog Theatre
  7. The Women of Lockerbie, SATE
  8. Nonsense and Beauty, The Rep
  9. Time Stands Still, New Jewish
  10. Oslo, The Rep

Best Dramatic Production

The Crucible at Stray Dog Theatre
  1. Angels in America, The Rep
  2. District Merchants, New Jewish
  3. The Crucible, Stray Dog
  4. Photograph 51, West End Players Guild
  5. Indecent, Max and Louie Productions
  6. Nonsense and Beauty, The Rep
  7. The Night of the Iguana, Tennessee Williams Festival St. Louis
  8. Oslo, The Rep
  9. Time Stands Still, New Jewish
  10. Farragut North, St. Louis Actors’ Studio

MUSICAL AWARDS

Casr of Cry-Baby at New Line

Best Musical Director
1. Ryan Fielding Garrett, “Kinky Boots,” The Muny
2. Jennifer Buchheit, “The Who’s Tommy,” Stray Dog Theatre
3. Nicolas Valdez, “Cry-Baby,” New Line Theatre
4. Charles Creath, “Don’t Both Me I Can’t Cope,” The Black Rep
5. Nicolas Valdez, “Be More Chill,” New Line Theatre
6. Scott Schoonover, “Daddy Long Legs,” Insight Theatre
7. Holly Barber, “Hedwig and the Angry Inch,” The Q Collective

Don’t Bother Me I Can’t Cope at The Black Rep

Best Choreographer (and not just in musicals)

1. Kirven Douthit-Boyd, “Don’t Bother Me I Can’t Cope,” The Black Rep
2. Mike Hodges, “Guys and Dolls,” Stray Dog Theatre
3. Rusty Mowery, “Kinky Boots,” The Muny
4. Ellen Isom, “Indecent,” Max and Louie Productions
5. Tony Gonzalez, “Grease,” Stages St. Louis
6. Heather Beal, “Feeding Beatrice,” The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis

Best Supporting Actress in a Musical

Taylor Louderman in “Kinky Boots”
  1. Taylor Louderman, “Kinky Boots,” The Muny
  2. Michelle Ragusa, “The Boy from Oz,” Stages St. Louis
  3. Sarah Gene Dowling, “Hedwig and the Angry Inch,” The Q Collective
  4. Kendra Lynn Lucas, “Grease,” Stages St. Louis
  5. Khalia Johnson, “Footloose,” The Muny
  6. Eleanor Humphrey, “Dreamgirls,” Stray Dog Theatre
  7. Laura Michelle Kelley, “Matilda,” The Muny
  8. Grace Langford, “Avenue Q,” The Playhouse at Westport
  9. Jenny Powers, “1776,” The Muny
    10. Tateonna Thompson, “Dreamgirls,” Stray Dog
    10. Denise Thimes, “Don’t Bother Me, I Can’t Cope,” The Black Rep

Best Actress in a Musical

Ebony Easter as Effie in “Dreamgirls” (center)
  1. Ebony Easter, “Dreamgirls,” Stray Dog Theatre
  2. Jennifer Theby-Quinn, “Daddy Long Legs,” Insight Theatre
  3. Mattea Conforti, “Matilda,” The Muny
  4. Kendra Kassebaum, “Guys and Dolls,” The Muny
  5. Mamie Parris, “Paint Your Wagon,” The Muny
  6. Sarah Rae Womack, “Guys and Dolls,” Stray Dog Theatre
  7. Brittany Bradford, “Guys and Dolls,” The Muny
Zak Farmer in “La Cage Aux Folles” at New line

Best Actor in a Musical
1. Zachary Allen Farmer, “La Cage Aux Folles,” New Line Theatre
2. J. Harrison Ghee, “Kinky Boots,” The Muny
3. David Elder, “The Boy from Oz,” Stages St. Louis
4. Luke Steingruby, “Hedwig and the Angry Inch,” The Q Collective
5. Caleb Miofsky, “Cry-Baby,” New Line Theatre
6. James Patterson, “Man of La Mancha,” Stages St. Louis
7. Mark Kelley, “A Man of No Importance,” R-S Theatrics

Best Supporting Actor in a Musical

Kevin Corpuz, right in “Be More Chill” at New Line
  1. Omega Jones, “Dreamgirls,” Stray Dog Theatre
  2. Kevin Corpuz, “Be More Chill,” New Line Theatre
  3. Omar Lopez-Cepero, “Paint Your Wagon,” The Muny
  4. Tristan Davis, “The Who’s Tommy,” Stray Dog Theatre
  5. Eli Mayer, “Footloose,” The Muny
  6. Ryan Cooper, “Man of La Mancha,” Stages St. Louis
  7. Ken Page, “Guys and Dolls,” Stages St. Louis
  8. Mike Wells, “Guys and Dolls,” Stray Dog Theatre
  9. Patrick John Moran, “Man of La Mancha,” Stages St. Louis
  10. Zach Stefaniak, “Guys and Dolls,” Stray Dog Theatre
    (tie) Ben Davis, “1776,” The Muny
Avenue Q at the Playhouse at Westport

Best Director of a Musical

1. Mike Dowdy-Windsor and Scott Miller, “Be More Chill,” New Line Theatre
2. DB Bonds, “Kinky Boots,” The Muny
3. Justin Been, “Dreamgirls,” Stray Dog Theatre
4. Lee Anne Mathews, “Avenue Q,” The Playhouse at Westport
5. Jordan Woods, “Hedwig and the Angry Inch,” The Q Collective
6. Ron Himes, “Don’t Bother Me, I Can’t Cope,” The Black Rep

A Man of No Importance


Best Ensemble in a Musical
1. “Kinky Boots,” The Muny
2
. “Dreamgirls.” Stray Dog Theatre
3. “Avenue Q,” The Playhouse at Westport
4. “Be More Chill,” New Line Theatre
5. “A Man of No Importance,” R-S Theatrics
6. . Don’t Bother Me I Can’t Cope,” The Black Rep
7. “Man of La Mancha,” Stages St. Louis
8. “Cry-Baby,” New Line Theatre

“Kinky Boots” at the Muny

Best Musical Production

1.“Kinky Boots,” The Muny
2. “Dreamgirls.” Stray Dog Theatre
3. “Be More Chill,” New Line Theatre
4. “Avenue Q,” The Playhouse at Westport
5. “Don’t Bother Me I Can’t Cope,” The Black Rep

?Dreamgirls”

Best Costume Design of a Musical

1. Sarah Porter, “La Cage Aux Folles,” New Line Theatre
2. Julian King, “Dreamgirls,” Stray Dog Theatre”
3. Mary Engelbreit and Leon Dobkowski, “Matilda,” The Muny
4. Brad Musgrove, “101 Dalmatians,” Stages St. Louis
5. Brad Musgrove, “Grease,” Stages St. Louis
6. Eileen Engel, “The Who’s Tommy,” Stray Dog Theatre
7. Gregg Barnes and Lindsay McWilliams, “Kinky Boots,’ The Muny

“The Who’s Tommy”

Best Lighting Design in a Musical

1. Tyler Duenow, “The Who’s Tommy,” Stray Dog
2. Joe Clapper, “Don’t Bother Me I Can’t Cope,” The Black Rep
3. Rob Lippert, “Be More Chill,” New Line Theatre
4. John Lasiter, “Paint Your Wagon,” The Muny
5. Tyler Duenow, “Dreamgirls,” Stray Dog Theatre
6. Sean M. Savoie, “The Boy from Oz,” Stages St. Louis

“Matilda” at the Muny

Best Set Design in a Musical

1. Mary Engelbreit and Paige Hathaway, “Matilda,” The Muny
2. James Wolk, “Man of La Mancha,” Stages St. Louis
3. Josh Smith, “The Who’s Tommy,” Stages St. Louis
4. Michael Schweikardt, “Paint Your Wagon,” The Muny
5. Peter and Margery Spack, “Don’t Bother Me I Can’t Cope,” The Black Rep

Feeding Beatrice

Best Sound Design of a Play

  1. Broken Chord, Angels in America, The Rep
  2. Ellie Schwetye, The Night of the Iguana, Tennessee Williams Festival
  3. David Samba, Feeding Beatrice, The Rep
  4. Kareem Deanes, Fully Committed, New Jewish Theatre
  5. Philip Evans, Indecent, Max and Louie Productions
    6. Justin Been, The Crucible, Stray Dog Productions
“Love’s Labors Lost”

Best Costume Design in a Play

  1. Michele Friedman Siler, Brighton Beach Memoirs, New Jewish
  2. Melissa Trn, Love’s Labors Lost, Shakespeare Festival St. Louis
  3. Felia Davenport, District Merchants, New Jewish
  4. Andrea Robb, A Life in the Theater, St. Louis Actors’ Studio
  5. Laura Hanson, Wittenberg, Upstream Theatre

Best Set Design in a Play

The Night of the Iguana
  1. Peter and Margery Spack, The Play That Goes Wrong, The Rep
  2. Dunsi Dai, The Night of the Iguana, Tennessee Williams Festival St. Louis
  3. Peter and Margery Spack, Brighton Beach Memoirs, New Jewish
  4. Kristin Cassidy, “Photograph 51,” West End Players Guild
  5. William Bloodgood, ‘Alabama Story,’ The Rep
  6. David Blake, “District Merchants,” New Jewish
  7. Lawrence E. Moten III, +Feeding Beatrice,” The Rep
    8. Patrick Huber, “True West,” St. Louis Actors’ Studio

Best Lighting Design in a Play

“Indecent”
  1. Jon Ontiveros, “The Night of the Iguana,” Tennessee Williams Festival St. Louis
  2. Xavier Pierce, “Angels in America,” The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis
  3. Patrick Huber, “Indecent,” Max and Louie Productions
  4. Jason Lynch, “Feeding Beatrice,” The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis
  5. Sean Savoie, “District Merchants,” New Jewish Theatre

Photo Credits: Phillip Hamer, Jon Gitchoff, JPatrick Huber, Joey Rumpell, Peter Wochniak and Jerry Naunheim Jr.