By Lynn Venhaus The laughs come in waves as wackiness ensues in “The Nerd,” a fizzy farce that showcases a nimble seven-member cast at their best.
Set in architect Willum Cubbert’s bachelor apartment in Terre Haute, Ind., in November 1981, what starts out as a typical drawing room two-act play soon turns into an outrageous comedy of manners that’s at once timeless and old-fashioned — but in a charming early ‘80s way. (Answering machine messages are a part of the humor).
Now on stage at the Strauss Black Box Theatre in the Kirkwood Performing Arts Center, the Moonstone Theatre Company’s fleet production accents the laugh-out-loud circumstances and plays up the absurd character traits in playwright Larry Shue’s clever classic.
As played by Oliver Bacus, Cubbert is an anxious people-pleaser. His two best buds are a snobby theater critic named Axel and an ambitious ‘weather girl’ named Tansy (also former girlfriend), who are moving along with their careers while he’s, well, ‘stuck in second gear’ to use The Rembrandts’ lyric to “I’ll Be There for You” (aka the “Friends” theme song).
And like that ensemble that just clicked together, Bacus, Bryce Miller and Bridgette Bassa are a tight trio, effortlessly conveying a realistic friendship and establishing their distinct personalities as the unusually named Willum, Axel, and Tansy.
Oliver Bacus, Bridgette Bassa, Bryce Miller. Photo by Jon Gitchoff
Miller adds the sour and Bassa brings the sweet to the mix. Miller superbly lobs sarcastic one-liners and keeps the disdain brewing as he demonstrates his adroit comedic skills.
Bassa, who has been memorable in such dramatic roles as the rebellious niece Jean in “August: Osage County” and as Billy’s girlfriend Sylvia in “Tribes,” both at St. Louis Actors’ Studio, shows her comedic chops again after appearing in “Grand Horizons” at Moonstone in March.
Noteworthy is her agility during back-and-forth trips between the kitchen and the living room while carrying food, keeping the show’s fast pace on track. And she is stylish encapsulating the typical early ‘80s chic career woman look by costume designer Michele Siler, along with the requisite big hair.
Willum’s concerned friends think he is too nice of a guy, and they encourage him to have more of a backbone because those habits have affected his decision-making. Nevertheless, he is trying to advance his career and persuade Tansy to resume their relationship and not move for a job elsewhere.
Ever loyal, Willum, a Vietnam War veteran, has talked about what he owes fellow soldier Rick Steadman for saving his life. During his ‘Nam service, he was seriously wounded, and while he never met the good Samaritan Rick, he feels indebted to him. In a letter, he wrote that as long as he was alive, Rick “will have somebody on Earth who will do anything for you.”
Ryan Lawson-Maeske, Photo by Jon Gitchoff.
Eager to collect the favor, Rick shows up one night, in the middle of a rather uncomfortable dinner party as Willum is trying to impress his hotel-owner client, who brought his wife, clearly ill at ease, and their rambunctious, spoiled son.
Weird timing, but Willum rolls with it, until he discovers just how peculiar Rick is and how disruptive he can be while staying as his houseguest. Pre-technology boom, the “nerd” definition was slightly different 42 years ago, and Ryan Lawson-Maeske embodies the socially inept, tone-deaf, unrefined guy in a full-throttle performance.
Accentuating the character’s oafishness, Lawson-Maeske affects a nasal, sing-song voice delivering goofy lines in a tactless way, and creating an awkward walk, so that his cadence and gait are funny no matter what he’s saying.
Bacus capably assumes the blander ‘straight’ man role because the eccentric people surrounding him need to standout. As an increasingly frustrated Willum, he feels put-upon, because this is a circus thrust upon him and people around him are demanding action in this escalating tug of war.
His exasperation and agitation grow as The Thing That Wouldn’t Leave wreaks havoc on his life. It all comes to a head when his friends concoct a ridiculous ‘foolproof’ scheme to send Rick on his merry way, and his domineering client is demanding immediate changes to his blueprints.
Kieran Thompson, Leslie Wobbe, Greg Johnston and Oliver Bacus. Photo by Jon Gitchoff.
It’s a tour-de-force comedic portrayal by the versatile Lawson-Maeske, who can easily move between comedy and drama on St. Louis stages. He fully commits to the madness, finding the sweet spot so that the growing animosity towards Rick’s obnoxious behaviors isn’t perceived as cruel, being hurtful to a hopeless cause.
Presenting the ‘work’ part of the dilemma is the irritating Waldgrave family, utilizing the synergy of veterans Greg Johnston as the blustery hotel magnate and Leslie Wobbe as his fretful wife, with Kieran Thompson displaying youthful energy as their bratty kid Thor.
Shue wrote two highly regarded comedies before his untimely death at age 39 in a commuter plane crash in 1985 — “The Nerd,” produced first in 1981, and “The Foreigner,” in 1984.
At first glance, the plays seem like tailor-made laugh fests with clever turns of phrase. Shue was gifted with remarkable verbal dexterity, and adds idiosyncratic touches – not just the odd names, but Rick is a factory chalk inspector? Tansy, playing hostess, brings out heaping bowls of three-bean salad and macaroni salad — quirky choices.
But Shue also underlined the human condition in such a way that we can relate. How many times do we need a push in life, that we must get out of our way to move forward?
With this ace cast under the shrewd and sharp-witted direction of Gary Wayne Barker, you expect a madcap romp but may be surprised by the heart the players have mustered, and what it has to say about work-life balance.
The ensemble moves easily around the nondescript apartment set designed by Dunsi Dai, with recognizable retro touches. While that is static, this cast is anything but, and their proficiency in making jokes land is admirable. Their timing is so crisp it doesn’t tip off any twists, either.
And I doubt anyone in the audience will be wanting cottage cheese any time soon.
Greg Johnston, Bridgette Bassa, Leslie Wobbe, Oliver Bacus and Bryce Miller. Photo by Jon Gitchoff.
Moonstone Theatre Company presents “The Nerd” July 6 – July 23 on Thursdays through Saturdays at 7:30 p.m. and Sundays at 2 p.m. in the Strauss Black Box Theatre at KPAC, 210 E. Monroe. General admission tickets are $40, with seniors $35 and students $15. For more information, visit moonstonetheatrecompany.com or call MetroTix at 314-534-1111.
Lynn (Zipfel) Venhaus has had a continuous byline in St. Louis metro region publications since 1978. She writes features and news for Belleville News-Democrat and contributes to St. Louis magazine and other publications.
She is a Rotten Tomatoes-approved film critic, currently reviews films for Webster-Kirkwood Times and KTRS Radio, covers entertainment for PopLifeSTL.com and co-hosts podcast PopLifeSTL.com…Presents.
She is a member of Critics Choice Association, where she serves on the women’s and marketing committees; Alliance of Women Film Journalists; and on the board of the St. Louis Film Critics Association. She is a founding and board member of the St. Louis Theater Circle.
She is retired from teaching journalism/media as an adjunct college instructor.
ST. LOUIS THEATER CIRCLE AWARDS RETURN FOR IN-PERSON GALA APRIL 3, 2023
TO HONOR OUTSTANDING WORK IN LOCAL PROFESSIONAL THEATER IN 2022
The Muny leads with 21 nominations, Stages St Louis has 19, The Black Rep 17 and Stray Dog Theatre 15
First In-Person Gala Since 2019 Due to Coronavirus Pandemic
ST. LOUIS, February 6, 2023 – After a four-year hiatus of not holding an in-person ceremony due to the coronavirus pandemic in 2020 through 2022, the St. Louis Theater Circle Awards will return April 3, 2023 in a ‘live’ ceremony beginning at 7 p.m. at the Loretto-Hilton Center on the campus of Webster University. The previous two events were streamed online by HEC Media.
Tickets at $23 apiece will soon be available at the box office of The Repertory Theatre of St. Louis at www.repstl.org or 314-968-4925, and also at the box office one hour before the ceremony.
Nominees in more than 30 categories will vie for honors covering comedies, dramas, musicals and operas produced by local professional theater and opera companies in the calendar years 2022. Approximately 90 productions have been considered for nominations for this year’s event. This compares to roughly 120 productions normally considered in one year alone prior to the pandemic.
Three productions – “Chicago” at The Muny, “A Christmas Carol” at The Rep, and “Head Over Heels” at New Line Theatre – were ineligible because the same production was presented within the last three years at the respective venues.
Nationally recognized playwright, theater producer, and long-time advocate for the arts Joan Lipkin will be honored with a special award for lifetime achievement.
The eighth annual award ceremony, which was to have been held at the Loretto-Hilton Center on the campus of Webster University, was cancelled in February 2020 due to the escalating number of cases of COVID-19. Instead, that event, honoring outstanding local theater productions for the year 2019, was held virtually in a highly polished presentation produced by HEC Media and streamed on HEC’s YouTube channel and web site. A ninth annual ceremony similarly was streamed on HEC Media for the combined years of 2020 and 2021.
The nominees for the 10th annual St. Louis Theater Circle Awards are:
Bronte Sister House Party, SATE. Photo by Joey Rumpell
Outstanding Supporting Performer in a Comedy, Female or Non-Binary Role
Cassidy Flynn, “Brontë Sister House Party,” SATE Hannah Geisz, “The Lonesome West,” West End Players Guild Jilanne Klaus, “Barefoot in the Park,” Moonstone Theatre Company Bess Moynihan, “Brontë Sister House Party,” SATE Valentina Silva, “The Rose Tattoo,” Tennessee Williams Festival St. Louis
Outstanding Supporting Performer in a Comedy, Male or Non-Binary Role
Ted Drury, “The Lonesome West,” West End Players Guild Joel Moses, “Brontë Sister House Party,” SATE Bradley Tejeda, “The Rose Tattoo,” Tennessee Williams Festival St. Louis Chauncy Thomas, “Much Ado About Nothing,” St. Louis Shakespeare Festival Eric Dean White, “Hand to God,” St. Louis Actors’ Studio
Molly Burris, Dear Jack Dear Louise
Outstanding Performer in a Comedy, Female or Non-Binary Role
Colleen Backer, “Hand to God,” St. Louis Actors’ Studio Molly Burris, “Dear Jack, Dear Louise,” New Jewish Theatre Rayme Cornell, “The Rose Tattoo,” Tennessee Williams Festival St. Louis Claire Karpen, “Much Ado About Nothing,” St. Louis Shakespeare Festival Rachel Tibbetts, “Brontë Sister House Party,” SATE
Jeff Kargus, Jason Meyers, “The Lonesome West” Photo by John Lamb
Outstanding Performer in a Comedy, Male or Non-Binary Role
Mitchell Henry-Eagles, “Hand to God,” St. Louis Actors’ Studio Jeff Kargus, “The Lonesome West,” West End Players Guild Ryan Lawson-Maeske, “Dear Jack, Dear Louise,” New Jewish Theatre Jason Meyers, “The Lonesome West,” West End Players Guild Stanton Nash, “Much Ado About Nothing,” St. Louis Shakespeare Festival
Joe Clapper, Behind the Sheet, Photo by Philip Hamer
Outstanding Lighting Design in a Play
Amina Alexander, “Stick Fly,” Repertory Theatre of St. Louis Jesse Alford, “The Rose Tattoo,” Tennessee Williams Festival St. Louis Joe Clapper, “Behind the Sheet,” The Black Rep Jasmine Williams, “Dontrell, Who Kissed the Sea,” The Black Rep John Wylie, “Much Ado About Nothing,” St. Louis Shakespeare Festival
Outstanding Sound Design
Lamar Harris, “Behind the Sheet,” The Black Rep Pornchanok (Nok) Kanchanabanca, “House of Joy,” Repertory Theatre of St. Louis Jackie Sharp, “Dontrell, Who Kissed the Sea,” The Black Rep Rusty Wandall, Kareem Deanes, “Much Ado About Nothing,” St. Louis Shakespeare Festival Amanda Werre, “Dear Jack, Dear Louise,” New Jewish Theatre
Joel Moses in “Laughter on the 23rd Floor,” New Jewish Theatre, Photo by Jon Gitchoff
Outstanding Costume Design in a Play
Dorothy Marshall Englis, “Much Ado About Nothing,” St. Louis Shakespeare Festival Liz Henning, “Brontë Sister House Party,” SATE Liz Henning, “Rodney’s Wife,” The Midnight Company Oona Natesan, “House of Joy,” Repertory Theatre of St. Louis Michele Friedman Siler, “Laughter on the 23rd Floor,” New Jewish Theatre
Outstanding Set Design in a Play
Dahlia Al-Habieli, “House of Joy,” Repertory Theatre of St. Louis Dunsi Dai, “Dear Jack, Dear Louise,” New Jewish Theatre Bess Moynihan, “Rodney’s Wife,” The Midnight Company Kyu Shin, “Stick Fly,” Repertory Theatre of St. Louis Josh Smith, “Much Ado About Nothing,” St. Louis Shakespeare Festival
Riley Carter Adams, right, The Bee Play, New Jewish Theatre. Photo by Jon Gitchoff.
Outstanding Supporting Performer in a Drama, Female or Non-Binary Role
Riley Carter Adams, “The Bee Play,” New Jewish Theatre Sarajane Alverson, “The Normal Heart,” Stray Dog Theatre Rachel Hanks, “The Christians,” West End Players Guild Rachel Tibbetts, “Rodney’s Wife,” The Midnight Company Sumi Yu, “House of Joy,” Repertory Theatre of St. Louis
Outstanding Supporting Performer in a Drama, Male or Non-Binary Role
Cameron Jamarr Davis, “The African Company Presents Richard III,” The Black Rep Joseph Garner, “The Christians,” West End Players Guild Michael James Reed, “Proof,” Moonstone Theatre Company Joey Saunders, “The Normal Heart,” Stray Dog Theatre Jeffrey Wright, “The Normal Heart,” Stray Dog Theatre
Summer Baer, Michael James Reed “Proof,” Moonstone Theatre Company.
Outstanding Performer in a Drama, Female or Non-Binary Role
Summer Baer, “Proof,” Moonstone Theatre Company Lavonne Byers, “Good People,” Stray Dog Theatre Kelly Howe, “Rodney’s Wife,” The Midnight Company Chinna Palmer, “Behind the Sheet,” The Black Rep Jennifer Theby-Quinn, “Iphigenia in Splott,” Upstream Theater
Outstanding Performer in a Drama, Male or Non-Binary Role
Kevin Brown, “Jitney,” The Black Rep Jeff Cummings, “Behind the Sheet,” The Black Rep Olajuwon Davis, “Jitney,” The Black Rep Joel Moses, “The Christians,” West End Players Guild Stephen Peirick, “The Normal Heart,” Stray Dog Theatre
“Jitney,” The Black Rep, Phillip Hamer photo
Outstanding New Play
“Bandera, Texas,” by Lisa Dellagiarino Feriend, Prism Theatre Company “Brontë Sister House Party,” by Courtney Bailey, SATE “The Good Ship St. Louis,” by Philip Boehm, Upstream Theater “Roll With It!” by Katie Rodriguez Banister and Michelle Zielinski, The Black Mirror Theatre Company “Winds of Change,” by Deanna Jent, St. Louis Shakespeare Festival
Outstanding Achievement in Opera
Daniela Candillari, “Carmen,” Opera Theatre of Saint Louis Thomas Glass, “Harvey Milk,” Opera Theatre of Saint Louis Karen Kanakis, “La Rondine,” Winter Opera Saint Louis Robert Mellon, “Falstaff,” Union Avenue Opera Sarah Mesko, “Carmen,” Opera Theatre of Saint Louis
Union Avenue Opera’s production of A Little Night Music on August 17, 2022.
Outstanding Production of an Opera
“Awakenings,” Opera Theatre of Saint Louis “Falstaff,” Union Avenue Opera “The Gondoliers,” Winter Opera Saint Louis “Harvey Milk,” Opera Theatre of Saint Louis “A Little Night Music,” Union Avenue Opera
Outstanding Musical Director
Cullen Curth, “Jerry’s Girls,” New Jewish Theatre Jermaine Hill, “The Color Purple,” The Muny Walter “Bobby” McCoy, “In the Heights,” Stages St. Louis James Moore, “Sweeney Todd,” The Muny Andrew Resnick, “The Karate Kid – The Musical,” Stages St. Louis
The Karate Kid – The Musical, Phillip Hamer photo.
Outstanding Choreographer
Dena DiGiacinto, “A Chorus Line,” Stages St. Louis Keone and Mari Madrid, “The Karate Kid – The Musical,” Stages St. Louis Patrick O’Neill, “Mary Poppins,” The Muny Josh Rhodes, “Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat,” The Muny Luis Salgado, “In the Heights,” Stages St. Louis
Outstanding Supporting Performer in a Musical, Female or Non-Binary Role
Tami Dahbura, “In the Heights,” Stages St. Louis Melissa Felps, “Something Rotten!” New Line Theatre Nicole Michelle Haskins, “The Color Purple,” The Muny Grace Langford, “The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee,” Stray Dog Theatre Dawn Schmid, “Ride the Cyclone,” Stray Dog Theatre
Marshall Jennings, Melissa Felps “Something Rotten!” New Line Theatre
Outstanding Supporting Performer in a Musical, Male or Non-Binary Role
Luis-Pablo Garcia, “In the Heights,” Stages St. Louis Clayton Humburg, “Something Rotten!” New Line Theatre Jeffrey Izquierdo-Malon, “Something Rotten!” New Line Theatre Marshall Jennings, “Something Rotten!” New Line Theatre Jordan Wolk, “Assassins,” Fly North Theatricals
Outstanding Lighting Design in a Musical
Tyler Duenow, “Ride the Cyclone,” Stray Dog Theatre Bradley King, “The Karate Kid – The Musical,” Stages St. Louis John Lasiter, “Sweeney Todd,” The Muny Sean M. Savoie, “A Chorus Line,” Stages St. Louis Sean M. Savoie, “In the Heights,” Stages St. Louis
“In the Heights,” Stages St. Louis, Photo by Phillip Hamer.
Outstanding Set Design in a Musical
Edward E. Hayes, Jr. and Greg Emetaz, “Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat,” The Muny Anna Louizos, “In the Heights,” Stages St. Louis Derek McLane, “The Karate Kid – The Musical,” Stages St. Louis Michael Schweikardt, “Sweeney Todd,” The Muny Josh Smith, “Ride the Cyclone,” Stray Dog Theatre
Outstanding Costume Design in a Musical
Eileen Engel, “A Little Night Music,” Stray Dog Theatre Eileen Engel, “Assassins,” Fly North Theatricals Samantha C. Jones, “The Color Purple,” The Muny Brad Musgrove, “In the Heights,” Stages St. Louis Alejo Vietti, “Sweeney Todd,” The Muny
Anastacia McCleskey, “The Color Purple,” Phillip Hamer photo.
Outstanding Performer in a Musical, Female or Non-Binary Role
Carmen Cusack, “Sweeney Todd,” The Muny Jeanna De Waal, “Mary Poppins,” The Muny Eileen Engel, “Ride the Cyclone,” Stray Dog Theatre Melissa Felps, “Urinetown,” New Line Theatre Anastacia McCleskey, “The Color Purple,” The Muny
Outstanding Performer in a Musical, Male or Non-Binary Role
Ryan Alvarado, “In the Heights,” Stages St. Louis Corbin Bleu, “Mary Poppins,” The Muny Ben Davis, “Sweeney Todd,” The Muny Stephen Henley, “Assassins,” Fly North Theatricals Jovanni Sy, “The Karate Kid – The Musical,” Stages St. Louis
Stephen Henley, The Balladeer, Fly North Theatricals.
Outstanding Ensemble in a Comedy
“Brontë Sister House Party,” SATE “Heroes,” Albion Theatre “Laughter on the 23rd Floor,” New Jewish Theatre “A Midsummer Night’s Dream,” St. Louis Shakespeare Festival “Much Ado About Nothing,” St. Louis Shakespeare Festival
Outstanding Ensemble in a Drama
“The African Company Presents Richard III,” The Black Rep “Behind the Sheet,” The Black Rep “The Christians,” West End Players Guild “Jitney,” The Black Rep “The Normal Heart,” Stray Dog Theatre
The Christians, West End Players Guild, Photo by John Lamb
Outstanding Ensemble in a Musical
“The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee,” Stray Dog Theatre “A Chorus Line,” Stages St. Louis “The Color Purple,” The Muny “In the Heights,” Stages St. Louis “Sweeney Todd,” The Muny
Outstanding Director of a Comedy
Robert Ashton, “The Lonesome West,” West End Players Guild Eddie Coffield, “Laughter on the 23rd Floor,” New Jewish Theatre David Kaplan, “The Rose Tattoo,” Tennessee Williams Festival St. Louis Keating, “Brontë Sister House Party,” SATE Bruce Longworth, “Much Ado About Nothing,” St. Louis Shakespeare Festival
“Rodney’s Wife,” The Midnight Company, Photo by Joey Rumpell
Outstanding Director of a Drama
Gary F. Bell, “The Normal Heart,” Stray Dog Theatre Joe Hanrahan, “Rodney’s Wife,” The Midnight Company Ron Himes, “The African Company Presents Richard III,” The Black Rep Ron Himes, “Behind the Sheet,” The Black Rep Ellie Schwetye, “The Christians,” West End Players Guild
Outstanding Director of a Musical
Lili-Anne Brown, “The Color Purple,” The Muny Scott Miller, “Something Rotten!” New Line Theatre Bradley Rohlf, “Assassins,” Fly North Theatricals Rob Ruggiero, “Sweeney Todd,” The Muny Luis Salgado, “In the Heights,” Stages St. Louis
“Much Ado About Nothing,” St Louis Shakespeare Festival
Outstanding Production of a Comedy
“Brontë Sister House Party,” SATE “Dear Jack, Dear Louise,” New Jewish Theatre “The Lonesome West,” West End Players Guild “Much Ado About Nothing,” St. Louis Shakespeare Festival “The Rose Tattoo,” Tennessee Williams Festival St. Louis
“The African Company Presents Richard III,” The Black Rep, Photo by Phillip Hamer
Outstanding Production of a Drama
“The African Company Presents Richard III,” The Black Rep “Behind the Sheet,” The Black Rep “Good People,” Stray Dog Theatre “Jitney,” The Black Rep “The Normal Heart,” Stray Dog Theatre
Outstanding Production of a Musical
“Assassins,” Fly North Theatricals “The Color Purple,” The Muny “In the Heights,” Stages St. Louis “Ride the Cyclone,” Stray Dog Theatre “Sweeney Todd,” The Muny
“Ride the Cyclone,” Stray Dog Theatre, Photo by John Lamb
Special Award
Joan Lipkin, for lifetime achievement
Joan Lipkin
The mission of the St. Louis Theater Circle is simple: To honor outstanding achievement in St. Louis professional theater. Other cities around the country, such as Boston, Chicago, Los Angeles, Philadelphia, San Diego, San Francisco and Washington, D.C., pay tribute to their own local theatrical productions with similar awards programs.
Members of the St. Louis Theater Circle include Steve Allen (stagedoorstl.com); Mark Bretz (LadueNews); Bob Cohn (St. Louis Jewish Light); Tina Farmer (The Riverfront Times); Michelle Kenyon (snoopstheatrethoughts.com and KDHX); Gerry Kowarsky (Two on the Aisle, HEC Media); Chuck Lavazzi (KDHX); Rob Levy (Broadwayworld.com); Judith Newmark (judyacttwo.com); Lynn Venhaus (PopLifeSTL.com); Bob Wilcox (Two on theAisle, HEC Media); and Calvin Wilson (St. Louis Post-Dispatch). Eleanor Mullin, local performer and arts supporter, is group administrator.
Lynn (Zipfel) Venhaus has had a continuous byline in St. Louis metro region publications since 1978. She writes features and news for Belleville News-Democrat and contributes to St. Louis magazine and other publications.
She is a Rotten Tomatoes-approved film critic, currently reviews films for Webster-Kirkwood Times and KTRS Radio, covers entertainment for PopLifeSTL.com and co-hosts podcast PopLifeSTL.com…Presents.
She is a member of Critics Choice Association, where she serves on the women’s and marketing committees; Alliance of Women Film Journalists; and on the board of the St. Louis Film Critics Association. She is a founding and board member of the St. Louis Theater Circle.
She is retired from teaching journalism/media as an adjunct college instructor.
With its jaunty game-show music and kicky retro fashions, Moonstone Theatre Company’s staging of Neil Simon’s “Barefoot in the Park” is a throwback to amiable, innocuous 1960s-era sitcoms.
Only the Wayback Machine hasn’t been kind to Simon’s first major success in 1963, a fluffy lighthearted comedy about a couple with opposite personalities starting married life. They live in a fifth-floor walk-up apartment in Manhattan’s Greenwich Village, which becomes a running gag.
A smash hit that ran four years on Broadway, the breezy trifle was directed by Mike Nichols, garnered four Tony nominations and he won for directing. In 1967, the popular movie adaptation paired Robert Redford, the original Paul on stage, with Jane Fonda as the ditzy Corie, and the sublime Mildred Natwick recreated her scene-stealing timid mother role. The play went on to be a beloved staple of school, community, and dinner theater. It was a go-to during high school speech meets for duet-acting partners back in my day.
But that was then, and this is now.
Sixty years later, it’s flimsy rather than frothy — a period piece that probably wouldn’t make the cut for a 1960s-time capsule if selections were today, despite Simon’s hit-making machine status.
The antiquated attitudes on wives and mothers are hard to surmount – we’ve come a long way, baby. I suppose looking back at the pre-feminism years reinforces how times have changed. But engaging? Not so much.
The dialogue reflecting the time’s societal mores is sometimes cringy. Corie’s widowed mom advises: “Make him feel important. Give up a little of yourself. If you do that, you’ll have a happy and wonderful marriage — like two out of every 10 couples.”
Moonstone has set the show in 1966. The cast tries hard to toss off one-liners with some pizzazz but are hampered by how dated the wisecracks sound.
However, the cast gets the rhythm of Simon’s trademark patter, and the genial performers supply several bright spots because of their commitment to the characters.
Particularly funny are well-known veteran actors Chuck Brinkley, who plays the jovial telephone repairman – back when rotary dial was standard, and a Princess phone was fancy — and Bob Harvey, doing funny physical schtick as a huffing-and-puffing delivery man. Ever reliable, the old pros’ brief bits are amusing.
Appealing performers Luis Aguilar and Rhiannon Creighton convey the newlyweds and do what they can to enliven the creaky conversations, but the thinly drawn Mr. and Mrs. Bratter roles have never seemed so bland. They move in after a 6-day honeymoon, and all the character tics appear to aggravate.
This depiction, when the man was the breadwinner and the woman was the happy homemaker, is simply stale.
While cheery and sweet at times, bride Corie does come off as clingy, whiny, and shallow in other moments. Intended as an early image of Simon’s adored first wife Joan, Corie is not as interesting as screwball heroines of days gone by because there’s not much character development. She’s advertised as a ‘free spirit’ but seems tamer in retrospect.
Domestic bliss is threatened because she fears her fuddy-duddy lawyer husband, who is trying to concentrate on his job, will never be spontaneous, like she is. For instance, he wouldn’t walk barefoot in Central Park on a frigid winter day.
Luis Aguilar and Rhiannon Creighton. Photo by Jon Gitchoff
Faring better, although stuck in the tired stereotype of hovering suburban mom, is Jilanne Klaus as widowed Ethel. She’s in her 50s, an empty nester in New Jersey, and dull as dishwater. But she will soften and lighten up. Oh, the agism jokes! Let’s get the retirement home ready!
Corie’s perturbed that mom keeps sending wedding presents almost daily from Lord and Taylor. Oh, the horror.
The hijinks ramp up when Corie fixes up her uptight mother with the nutty neighbor Victor Velasco for a dinner double date. Starting off with exotic gourmet food and braggadocio, the eccentric Hungarian charms the ladies, but Paul immediately dislikes the international man of mystery.
And the night, fueled by assorted alcoholic beverages and dinner in Staten Island (offstage), gets wild and crazy – especially for the stick-in-the-mud mom and husband. But Corie and Victor are kindred spirits.
Slapstick-y wackiness ensues, and Aguilar deftly displays a flair for physical comedy. TJ Lancaster wisely decides not to go too over-the-top playing the live-wire lothario who lives in the attic. He and Klaus demonstrate they are smart, instinctual performers whose crisp comic timing and ease on stage is a plus.
Those two gave a master class in recalibrating their moves when the pair, mindful of a hump in the set’s area rug, acted nonplussed and went on with the show, careful where they stepped during Friday night’s third act.
When the inevitable blow-up occurs in act two – because Paul is a “watcher” and Corie is a “doer,” the couple’s bickering becomes tedious while we’re waiting for the happy-ever-after resolution. No suspense there. Although the fact they didn’t realize their differences before wouldn’t seem to bode well for the future (nevertheless, the Simons were married for 20 years until Joan’s death from cancer at age 41).
One of the most commercially successful playwrights of all-time, Simon, who started writing comedy sketches in the pioneering days of early television, made a career out of first world problems – only the world never really intruded into his work until the brilliant Eugene trilogy, starting with “Brighton Beach Memoirs.”
His customary white middle-class struggles were usually connected to relationship clashes, poking fun at human foibles and using self-deprecating humor, which frequently included Jewish characters in urban settings.
So, the pleasant bon mots and jokes on the squalor of a tiny big-city apartment are expected.
Only, the set isn’t so small. While acclaimed scenic designer Dunsi Dai’s work is a perfect palette of pastels reflecting the time, and his skylight is certainly a “Wow,” it’s too spacious for a supposedly cramped one-bedroom apartment. (If you have been in modest New York City apartments, you know, unless you assume they’re all like “Friends.”)
And the setting is not practical for stage movement, for Creighton must scamper quite a bit – it’s a good thing she’s energetic because we watch her take a lot of steps as she crisscrosses for unpacking, decorating and scene requirements. In a modern setting, she’d be killing it on Fitbit. Director Sharon Hunter’s blocking seems clunky because of the larger dimensions.
Patrick Sullivan’s striking lighting design capably illuminates the night sky, and Amanda Werre’s sound design is smooth.
Michele Siler’s costume designs are noteworthy, having ideally captured the period’s everyday apparel for the women, and Emily Fluchel nails the props – the suitcases, kitchen wares and knickknacks.
Despite it being Simon’s longest-running hit, this would be difficult to pull off in any 21st century theater because it feels synthetic. Nevertheless, the performers’ chemistry and nimble line delivery elicit laughs.
Like so many other plays that depend on a mundane premise to begin with, “Barefoot in the Park” is an unusual classic to present because of the shift in male-female dynamics. No amount of rejuvenation can resuscitate it, despite this likable ensemble and their earnest efforts.
Moonstone Theatre Company presents Neil Simon’s comedy “Barefoot in the Park” from Oct. 27 through Nov. 13 at the Kirkwood Performing Arts Center’s black box theatre, 210 E. Monroe Ave. Showtimes are Thursdays through Saturdays at 7:30 p.m. and Sundays at 2 p.m., except there is no show on Friday, Nov. 11, and two shows on Saturday, Nov. 12, at 3 p.m. and 7:30 p.m. For tickets or for more information, visit: www.moonstonetheatrecompany.com.
Jilanne Klaus, Rhiannon Creighton, Luis Aguilar. Photo by Jon Gitchoff
Lynn (Zipfel) Venhaus has had a continuous byline in St. Louis metro region publications since 1978. She writes features and news for Belleville News-Democrat and contributes to St. Louis magazine and other publications.
She is a Rotten Tomatoes-approved film critic, currently reviews films for Webster-Kirkwood Times and KTRS Radio, covers entertainment for PopLifeSTL.com and co-hosts podcast PopLifeSTL.com…Presents.
She is a member of Critics Choice Association, where she serves on the women’s and marketing committees; Alliance of Women Film Journalists; and on the board of the St. Louis Film Critics Association. She is a founding and board member of the St. Louis Theater Circle.
She is retired from teaching journalism/media as an adjunct college instructor.
The COVID-19 pandemic presents a multitude of obstacles to overcome for organizations of all types, and theater groups are no exception. Sharon Hunter, Artistic Director-Producer of Moonstone Theatre Company, aims to help address some of the virus-related challenges that the St. Louis theatre community faces by forming the St. Louis Theatre Community Task Force.
“As I was thinking about how to proceed with my own company in the wake of the pandemic, I started thinking it would be helpful to get a lot of the theaters to sit down via Zoom and discuss concerns, ideas and solutions for moving forward as we navigate the future of theatre in St. Louis,” Hunter explains.
Sharon Hunter
The Task Force will address concerns including conducting safe auditions, rehearsals and performances, finding new ways to seat audiences, maintaining the visibility of the St. Louis theatre community, new ways to offer theatre experiences and recommendations for the use of personal protective equipment.
Hunter said the Task Force, which is the first of its kind in the St. Louis area, welcomes local theatre groups of all sizes. In addition to these organizations, representatives from the St. Louis County Department of Health and the Center For Disease Control have also been invited to the first online meeting to address questions and concerns.
Theatre companies invited to participate include R-S Theatrics, The Q Collective, The Midnight Company, Slightly Askew Theatre Ensemble, Upstream Theater, Repertory Theatre of St. Louis, COCA, Shakespeare Festival STL, Black Rep, Stray Dog Theatre, Stages St. Louis, St. Louis Actors’ Studio, The Muny, Opera Theatre of Saint Louis, New Jewish Theatre, Cherokee Street Theatre, The Cabaret Project of St. Louis, Max & Louie Productions, Black Mirror Theatre, Young Liars, West End Players Guild, Tennessee Williams Festival St Louis, New Line Theatre, ERA Theatre Company, STL Fringe Festival, St Louis Shakespeare, Metro Theatre Company, That Uppity Theatre Company and the Tesseract Theatre Company.
The initial meeting of the Task Force is scheduled for Thursday, April 23, at 7 p.m. Theatre groups interested in interested in participating should contact Hunter at moonstonetheatrestl@gmail.com to get access to the Zoom link. For more info, check their Facebook page for updates: https://www.facebook.com/STLTheatre/.
Lynn (Zipfel) Venhaus has had a continuous byline in St. Louis metro region publications since 1978. She writes features and news for Belleville News-Democrat and contributes to St. Louis magazine and other publications.
She is a Rotten Tomatoes-approved film critic, currently reviews films for Webster-Kirkwood Times and KTRS Radio, covers entertainment for PopLifeSTL.com and co-hosts podcast PopLifeSTL.com…Presents.
She is a member of Critics Choice Association, where she serves on the women’s and marketing committees; Alliance of Women Film Journalists; and on the board of the St. Louis Film Critics Association. She is a founding and board member of the St. Louis Theater Circle.
She is retired from teaching journalism/media as an adjunct college instructor.
