By Alex McPherson

A sincere and impressively well-acted reminder of the power of community to persevere through adversity, director Josephine Stewart-Te Whiu’s debut feature, “We Were Dangerous,” shines a warm, hopeful light through the darkness.

The film is set in 1954 and begins at New Zealand’s School for Incorrigible and Delinquent Girls, where the free-spirited and courageous Nellie (Erana James) plots an escape from the institution with her best friend, the younger but no less resilient Daisy (Manaia Hall), and her other Māori classmates.

Their class instructor, The Matron (an alternately satiric and terrifying Rima Te Wiata), aims to “correct” these girls through her three education principles: “Christianize, civilize, and assimilate.” The program attempts to restrict the girls’ free will and independence each step of the way. 

When Nellie’s escape attempt fails, just a few inches from clearing the gate, The Matron is instructed by her superiors to relocate her class to a small island previously used as a leper colony. This renders their chance of escape and risk of pregnancy moot, given that the only man there is the island’s bumbling caretaker, Barry (Stephen Tamarapa).

Nellie and Daisy’s group are accompanied by some new arrivals to the program, including the mysterious and confident Lou (Nathalie Morris), who Nellie and Daisy strike up a fast friendship with. The three of them room together in a ramshackle hut with a leaky ceiling. As the girls spend their days doing manual labor and enduring mind-numbing lessons about religion and female etiquette under The Matron’s eye, their vibrant spirits endure, and their bond strengthens, despite their bleak circumstances. 

But when the institution begins running sterilization experiments on the girls, Nellie, Daisy, and Lou must fight back against The Matron and her superiors before it’s too late.

“We Were Dangerous,” executive produced by Taika Waititi, isn’t a downbeat film,  despite the tough subject matter. Stewart-Te Whiu positions the lead characters as heroes resisting the systems trying to shape their identities, complete with a surprisingly light touch that works as its own sort of defiance against their grim reality and the morose nature of many period dramas. 

It’s definitely a choice that risks sugarcoating the timely issues on display if used in the wrong hands. Luckily, the performances and rich visuals give “We Were Dangerous” a soulful weight that elevates the sometimes archetypal nature of a screenplay that, for all its wry and rousing sensibilities, can’t quite do justice to the characters at its center.

Stewart-Te Whiu doesn’t wallow in the sadness and horror, but doesn’t underplay it either, striking a seriocomic tone that brings to mind Waititi’s work in its balancing of the harrowing and humorous. “We Were Dangerous” almost plays like a comedy at certain points, with the girls’ wit and playfulness contrasting with The Matron’s ghastly actions and the antiquated ideas of womanhood being forced upon them.  

Cam Ballantyne’s score, too, is lively and energetic, reflecting the continued hope and moments of happiness found scattered amid the abuse and drudgery they endure under The Matron’s watch. María Inés Manchego’s cinematography captures a vivid beauty alongside chilling isolation in the island’s untouched landscapes.

James brings rousing confidence and heartbreaking vulnerability to Nellie, who was forced to attend the school after being caught shoplifting in Christchurch. She had  been sent there by her family to live with a relative, but ultimately left to survive on her own.

Nellie is a surrogate big sister for Daisy, brought to life by Hall with a playful innocence belying Daisy’s trauma and determination to not have her “wild” spirit be tamed. Morris brings a mischievous energy to her performance as Lou, rejected by her well-off family and sent away to the school due to her sexuality.

James, Hall, and Morris have terrific chemistry, and their dynamic is tangible and grounded. It’s easy to buy them as a surrogate family unit, even though Stewart-Te Whiu and Maddie Dai’s screenplay rushes through their initial bonding without giving enough space for it to develop organically. 

Their connection feels a bit schematic as a result, especially during late-game plot beats that half-heartedly explore the risks and benefits of rebellion with the foot firmly on the gas pedal, building towards a near-fantastical conclusion. Indeed, the film’s 82-minute runtime is both efficient and limiting.

Stewart-Te Whiu is clearly intentional with what she focuses on — foregrounding the defiant joy and strong, distinct personalities of the girls above all else — but the film’s insistence on being inspirational also robs more traditionally dramatic character moments of the weight and consideration they deserve.

Narration by The Matron is woven throughout the plot — she explains Nellie, Daisy, and Lou’s backstories through her own point of view, flashbacks included — and while this decision successfully illustrates the contrast between The Matron’s warped worldview and reality, it also condenses these women’s stories to a semi-frustrating degree.

Still, the performances truly elevate the proceedings, revealing complexity not always afforded by the screenplay. 

Te Wiata, for example, chews scenery to a nasty, memorable pulp as The Matron, but we can see for ourselves, through subtle mannerisms, the self-hatred that percolates as a result of embodying the misogyny she was herself indoctrinated into as a young Māori teenager once searching for purpose — perhaps recognizing that it’s easier to conform than to embrace her own individuality.

Suffice to say, “We Were Dangerous” is an imperfect film, but one that features shades of greatness and that tells a worthy story while (in some respects) bucking convention. It’s disappointing that Stewart-Te Whiu opts for speed rather than necessary patience, but this remains both a serious-minded and life-affirming film that, especially in today’s troubled times, we can all take something from right now.

“We Were Dangerous” is a 2024 drama directed by Josephine Stewart-Te Whiu and starring Erana James, Manaia Hall, Rima Te Wiata, Nathalie Morris, and Stephen Tamarapa. Its runtime is 1 hour, 22 minutes, and it’s currently unrated. It opens at the Hi-Pointe Theatre May 9. Alex’s Grade: B