‘Wicked’ Enthralls, Frustrates in Long-Awaited Film Adaptation

‘Wicked’ Enthralls, Frustrates in Long-Awaited Film Adaptation

By Lynn Venhaus

A dazzling spectacle based on the 2003 Broadway musical fantasy, “Wicked” is overproduced and padded with unnecessarily stretched out musical numbers and extended scenes to present the popular culture phenomenon as only the first act in a 2 hour, 30-minute film.

After years in development, this long-awaited adaptation surely could have been pruned without affecting the story arc. The second act, “Wicked: Part II,” is set for a Nov. 21, 2025, release. Did it need to be this long? No. Is it worth your time? Yes.

With ‘wow factor’ production values and sensational performances, this vivid re-imagining of the Land of Oz is a must-see event best-suited for the big screen.

After opening Oct. 30, 2003, on Broadway, the beloved musical captured theatregoers’ fancy with its imaginative and sharp-witted story about the unlikely friendship between the Glinda the Good Witch of the North and Elphaba the Wicked Witch of the West. It draws from the familiar mythology based on the classic 1939 film “The Wizard of Oz” and L. Frank Baum’s series of 14 novels written between 1901-1917.

However, it is a prequel to those events, and takes place, for the most part, before farmgirl Dorothy Gale arrives from Kansas. But ‘Wicked,’ you see, is only a perception, and a misunderstood one at that. This inspired take fascinates with the green-skinned outcast Elphaba attending Shiz University, where she is taken on an unusual path, which leads to discovering her magical powers, and develops a bond with her mean-girl opportunist roommate Glinda, first known as “Galinda.”

As college students, the pair are exact opposite in looks, temperament, personality and values. Loosely based on Gregory Maguire’s 1995 novel, the screenplay is adapted by Winnie Holzman, the original musical book writer, who smartly gave us so much to ponder, and and Dana Fox, whose most recent credit is “Cruella.” Holzman created the TV series “My So-Called Life” and wrote for the landmark TV series “thirtysomething” and “Once and Again.”

The centerpiece is the glorious songs – those heartfelt, soaring, beautifully crafted numbers from virtuoso composer-lyricist Stephen Schwartz. He started his acclaimed five-decade career with “Godspell” in 1970, and has gone on to create “Pippin,” “Children of Eden,” “The Hunchback of Notre Dame,” “The Prince of Egypt,” and win an Oscar for “Colors of the Wind” from “Pocahontas.” This is arguably his masterpiece.

The film’s biggest strength is its perfectly cast triple-threat performers – Cynthia Erivo as Elphaba Thropp, Ariana Grande-Butera as Glinda Upland and Jonathan Bailey as Fiyero Tigelaar, a handsome prince whose subplot is best not spoiled.

Erivo’s knockout voice is her superpower. She won a Tony Award in 2016 as Celie in “The Color Purple” revival, the only non “Hamilton” cast member to win a musical acting trophy that year. She proves herself to be a gifted actress, as she leans into sympathetic Elphaba’s differences as a proud badge of honor, especially in her newfound activism against injustice.

Grande has sold more than 90 million records as a pop star and appeared on Nickelodeon and Broadway. If you’ve seen Grande host “Saturday Night Live,” you know she has terrific comic timing and unforced charm. As a singer, she has a four-octave vocal range and in this role, she inhabits the spoiled rich girl with a self-deprecating humor. She looks dainty, but there’s an intriguing power and intelligence behind the bubbly façade.

The charismatic Bailey, Emmy-nominated for “Fellow Travelers,” is known as the oldest son Anthony in the “Bridgerton” TV series, but in England, he is also an accomplished musical theater performer. He won an Olivier Award as Best Supporting Actor in a Musical for playing Jamie in the revival of “Company” in 2018. Fleet-footed and a nimble vocalist, he gives Fiyero an allure that wasn’t initially apparent on stage. (Fun fact: St. Louis’ own Norbert Leo Butz, two-time Tony winner, originated the role in its San Francisco tryout and on Broadway).

Outstanding in supporting roles are Jeff Goldblum as the morally compromised Wizard of Oz, who handles “A Sentimental Man” quite nicely, Michelle Yeoh as no-nonsense Shiz headmistress Madame Morrible, and Peter Dinklage, in a voice-over, as an animal professor, Dr. Dillamond, who’s frightened in “Something Bad,” tipping us off to sinister political forces (shades of authoritarianism and fascism ahead).

There are more-to-develop turns by Ethan Slater as Boq Woodsman, a Munchkin in love with Glinda, and Marissa Bode as Nessarose, Elphaba’s paraplegic younger sister. Slater was Tony-nominated and won a Drama Desk Award for his role as SpongeBob SquarePants in the 2017 Broadway musical. Stay tuned for some interesting twists with these two in Act 2.

New roles include Glinda’s fawning sycophants — Bowen Yang of SNL fame is Pfannee and Bronwyn James of CBS’ “Ghosts” is ShenShen.

As one who has seen the stage musical seven times, with an inaugural voyage to Chicago for the first national tour in May 2005 and the remainder at the Fabulous Fox in St. Louis, the film is faithful to the source material. (BTW, “Wicked” is considered “St. Louis’ favorite musical” after record-breaking runs here).

“One Short Day” is a grand introduction to the breathtaking art-deco Emerald City, Erivo’s emotional gravitas is displayed in “I’m Not That Girl,” and her humorous duet with Grande on a crisply delivered “What Is This Feeling?” is a highlight. Grande also shines in the peppy “Popular,” her signature song.

But the dramatic opener “No One Mourns the Wicked,” a too-heavy CGI-enhanced “The Wizard and I,” and an acrobatic “Dancing Through Life” set on library staircases are overstuffed. The choreography is in the contemporary style of elaborate and athletic dance moves with distinctive razzle-dazzle that is mega-staged for maximum effect.

That said, the defining showstopper, “Defying Gravity,” is everything you want it to be, an enthralling way to end, just before the curtain comes down on stage, but here with a “To be continued” card stunning the audience who doesn’t realize it’s only half.

Now the fourth longest-running musical of all-time, “Wicked” continues to draw packed houses in theaters around the world. While plans for a film adaptation started in 2012, the project did not kick off in earnest until 2021.

Jonathan M. Chu was hired to direct, after his successes with “Step Up 2 In the Streets,” “Step Up 3D,” “Crazy Rich Asians” and “In the Heights.” That was when it was decided to split the film into two parts to “meet the demands of the story’s epic scope and to expand upon the journeys of and relationships between the characters, without cutting any songs and major plot points” (I quote press here).

The second half is when more dark secrets and identities will be revealed, and features the moving “For Good” number. (No spoiler alert here, nor will I reveal cameos).

Highlights of Part 1 include the magnificent costume designs by Paul Tazewell, Tony Award winner for “Hamilton.” He must be the frontrunner for year-end awards, for each intricate outfit is stunning in detail.

The visual effects, while often over-the-top, are eye-popping. With today’s audiences conditioned for blockbuster franchise films, such as the Marvel Cinematic Universe, Harry Potter series, and new “Star Wars” chapters, these are the flamboyant excesses people expect, but I find them overdone.

The everlasting appeal of “Wicked” will always be as a timeless tale of love and friendship, and its brilliant way of presenting the proverbial “two sides to every story.” Those who cherish the musical can find moments to savor.

“Wicked” is a 2024 musical fantasy directed by Jon Chu and starring Cynthia Erivo, Ariana Grande-Butera, Jonathan Bailey, Jeff Goldblum, Michelle Yeoh, Ethan Slater, Marissa Bode, Bowen Yang and Bronwyn James. It is rated PG for some scary action, thematic material and brief suggestive material, and its runtime is 2 hours, 40 minutes. It opens in theatres Nov. 22. Lynn’s Grade: B+

‘Hamilton’ Continues to Resonate With Its Signature Style In a Fresh, Vibrant National Tour at The Fox

‘Hamilton’ Continues to Resonate With Its Signature Style In a Fresh, Vibrant National Tour at The Fox

By Lynn Venhaus

A civics lesson brimming with dreamers and doers, the world now knows the name of a game-changing genius with an extraordinary verbal dexterity, who teamed with a creative cabinet of generational talents at their pinnacle, to present the revolutionary musical “Hamilton” that’s a revelation.

Founding Father Alexander Hamilton, the first Secretary of the U.S. Treasury, is the central figure in this retelling of history and political scheming, a fascinating inside view on the messy political process.

This monumental work by Lin-Manuel Miranda, who spent seven years writing the book, music and lyrics, was assisted by visionary choreographer Andy Blankenbuehler, director Thomas Kail and Alex Lacamoire, who supervised the music and arranged the orchestrations, to create a synergy that is a thing of beauty.

Now playing at the Fox Theatre in St. Louis, this grand and glorious work courses with electricity, wit and the words to make us better people – and citizens. It speaks to us on so many levels.

This mostly sung epic opera incorporates hip hop, jazz, R & B, pop and Broadway show tunes in a richly dense tapestry. While the score deftly blends different styles, the aching ballads “It’s Quiet Uptown” and heartbreaking “Burn” provide emotional depth.

The use of hip-hop gives it a freshness, an urgency and a unique rhythm. Hamilton’s smackdown on state’s rights vs. federal power, “Cabinet Battle 1 and 2,” should be the standard now for all history classes.

So much history and attitude are packed into the songs. The introduction of “The Schuyler Sisters,” who play an integral part of Hamilton’s personal life, leads to Eliza (Lauren Maria Soosay) and Alexander (Tyler Fauntleroy) falling in love and marrying (“Helpless”) and Angelica’s yearning “Satisfied.” Both Soosay and Marja Harmon, as oldest sister Angelica, have strong melodious voices that bring out the fire and the heart in their songs.

The lyrics have become part of our modern fabric, now ‘catch phrases,’ and you will never get these infectious beats out of your head.

The theatrical world has not been the same since the cultural phenomenon about “the $10 founding father without a father who got a lot farther by working a lot harder by being a lot smarter by being a self-starter” opened off-Broadway nine years ago.

Since “Hamilton” debuted on Jan. 20, 2015, at The Public Theatre in New York City, the musical’s impressive ground-breaking elements cannot be understated.

Miranda was inspired by the Ron Chernow biography to make Hamilton the centerpiece of a hopeful reflection on America as an ‘unfinished symphony.’

How much we learn about this penniless orphaned immigrant from the West Indies is an absorbing history lesson. His gift was his ability to communicate through the written word and public speaking, and that propelled him to be a force in our nation’s founding and our system of government.

Add the dynamic of being Washington’s right-hand man and how he interacts with his political rival Burr adds a complexity – and it is riveting. He embodied the revolutionary spirit that started The American Experiment, and we see his evolution. But his flaws as well as his fears, desires and regrets, are on display, too.

The recurring themes make this musical so compelling. To Miranda-speak, characters must enunciate clearly. Miranda’s stunning verbal dexterity and ability to condense and rhyme history, and make it accessible, is why he is a certified genius.(Seriously, won one of the 2015 grants from the MacArthur Foundation—the so-called “Genius” fellowships.)

The most nominated musical ever on Broadway (16), winning 11, one shy of the record, and winner of the 2016 Pulitzer Prize for Drama, in addition to Olivier Awards, Grammy Awards and a 2021 Emmy Award for Outstanding Variety Special – Pre-Recorded for the filmed performances that were recorded on June 25-26, 2016, with the original cast at the Richard Rodgers Theatre in New York City. Miranda, Kail, Blankenbuehler and Lacamoire also received an unprecedented Kennedy Center Honor for it in 2018.

Its third tour here lives up to its incredible reputation and remains one of the most significant and vibrant works of art ever.

The greatest live theatrical experience of my lifetime is how I first described seeing “Hamilton” in April 2018 at the Fox. Now, after seeing it again in 2022 and on Aug. 28, in addition to watching the film, including the Sing-Along version on Disney +, its magnificence is timeless – and timely.

On opening night you could feel the audience’s palpable electricity, like in the past, but this time felt a little different because it has become “an event.” You could hear it in the crowd’s reaction, how they anticipated lines because they were familiar, and shared a unified feeling.

It’s a sense of how lucky we were to be alive right now, to see “Hamilton” again. Everyone smiled hearing people chuckle as Justin Matthew Sargent made his entrance as the pompous King George. His break-up song “You’ll Be Back” is a crowd-pleasing ‘60s pop ditty that adequately captures the monarchy our “young, scrappy and hungry” rebels overthrew. Sargent makes the most of his nine minutes.

This show is performed by the Angelica Tour, and St. Louis is only the second stop of their national tour that began in Fayetteville, Ark. Passionately presented, this vibrant company showcases the heartfelt connections. The care, skill and attention to detail is obvious.

Overall, this ensemble is stronger vocally than the 2022 touring company, with A. D. Weaver a highlight as George Washington – delivering a rousing “One Last Time” that drew a thunderous ovation.

Some of the principals have been involved in previous tours – including the first Angelica one, Philip one and And Peggy. And a few were on Broadway. Jared Howelton, who’s a nimble Marquis de Lafayette and slick Thomas Jefferson, was a principal standby at the Richard Rodgers Theatre.

Jimmy “JJ” Jeter, who plays the unprincipled Aaron Burr, was instead in the title role on Broadway. He soars in the show’s best songs “Wait for It,” “Non-Stop,” and “The Room Where It Happens.”

The total sensory package that is Miranda’s masterpiece again left me in awe about its creative force and everlasting impact. The words, music, performances, and technical brilliance are unforgettable.

How it continues to resonate and remain fresh with its innovative storytelling while still inspiring in a thrilling patriotic way is a remarkable achievement. As it seamlessly unfolds, you see why it draws people back to see it again and again.

“Hamilton” is a vivid portrait of an infant country, imbued with Miranda’s optimism about what can be achieved, because look at how we started and what we’ve overcome.

The Tony-winning lighting design by Howell Binkley and costume design by Paul Tazewell add to the storytelling, and scenic designer David Korins’ stunning functional brick-walled set with scaffolds, catwalks, staircases and dexterous use of the turntable, which did not win the Tony, keeps everything fluid.

Enhancing the effect is Blankenbuehler’s imaginative choreography. The performers are seemingly non-stop, as movement matters, punctuating the action, and creating this mesmerizing diorama.

Special shout-out to Nathanael Hirst of Belleville, who is a dancer, and portrays George Eacker (who shoots Philip Hamilton) and “Men No. 3.”

A musical about history that made history, it wasn’t as if Miranda was an unknown, but history sure had its eyes on him. He wrote and starred in the Tony-winning 2008 musical “In the Heights,” was co-composer and lyricist with Tom Kitt and Amanda Green for “Bring It On!” in 2011 (produced by the Mike Isaacson-led Fox Theatricals) and at Stephen Sondheim’s request, wrote Spanish dialogue and lyrics for the 2009 Broadway revival of “West Side Story.”

In 2009, Miranda was invited to the White House to share what he was working on during a night of poetry-inspired entertainment. President Barack and Michelle Obama were a little taken aback by his concept – a hip-hop concert album about a founding father who wasn’t president. Well, the rest, as they say, is history.

Since “Hamilton” became a landmark and won numerous accolades, Miranda has gone on to further acclaim. He directed the Jonathan Larson musical ‘tick, tick…Boom!” film adaptation in 2021, and performed in the animated film “Vivo,” musical adaptation “In the Heights,” and as Bert in “Mary Poppins Returns.”

He was Emmy-nominated as guest actor for hosting “Saturday Night Live” in 2016 and as guest actor on “Curb Your Enthusiasm” in 2018 and won an Emmy for producing the limited series “Fosse/Verdon.”

He has been nominated twice for Best Original Song at the Academy Awards, for the animated Disney movies “Moana” in 2017 and “Encanto” in 2022, and received two more Grammy Awards. He wrote original music for Disney’s live-action remake “The Little Mermaid” and the upcoming “Moana 2” and “Mufasa.” Still making history.

“Hamilton” remains a must-see. A swirling mix of craft, art and talent, “Hamilton” has a signature style that is unmatched. Seeing it again gives us a chance to discover new things and marvel over the rhythms and harmonies. Every performance makes America more beautiful.

Hamilton

The Fabulous Fox presents the national tour of “Hamilton” in St. Louis Aug. 28 – Sept. 8. For more information, visit www.fabulousfox.com and for tickets, www.metrotix.com. More tickets are released daily. There is a #Ham4Ham lottery, where the chosen 21 can purchase $10 tickets for 2. There are also rush tickets on Tuesdays, Thursdays and Sundays.

Note: The production photos by Joan Marcus are from a previous tour, not the current tour.

‘Hamilton’ the Movie Meets the Moment

‘Hamilton’ the Movie Meets the Moment

By Lynn Venhaus

The movie “Hamilton” meets the moment! Creator Lin-Manuel Miranda’s game-changer remains a vibrant experience five years after opening on Broadway. Its brilliance shines brightest with the original cast, and its synergy is a thing of beauty.

The cultural phenomenon “Hamilton,” the most nominated musical ever on Broadway and winner of the 2016 Pulitzer Prize for Drama, had two performances recorded on June 25-26, 2016, at the Richard Rodgers Theatre in New York City. This is after the musical won 11 Tony Awards, one shy of the record, and while the original cast was still intact. Founding Father Alexander Hamilton, the first Secretary of the U.S. Treasury, is the central figure in this retelling of history and political scheming. It also includes Hamilton’s family and romantic drama, based on Ron Chernow’s biography.

Miranda’s masterpiece is a hopeful reflection on the ‘unfinished symphony’ that is America – he presents a history lesson, inside view on the messy political process and an amalgam of modern and Broadway styles of music in a grand and glorious way.

Miranda, who wrote the book, music and lyrics, also stars in the title role. He cast black, Latino and Asian-Americans as the characters – “it is about America then as told by America now.” This ensemble is the gold standard – particularly Tony Award winners Leslie Odom Jr. as Aaron Burr, who resents the ambitious Hamilton’s easy climb; Daveed Diggs as loyal Lafayette in the first act and cocky Thomas Jefferson in the second; and Renee Elise Goldsberry as fiery Angelica Schuyler, whose sweet sister Eliza marries Hamilton; plus nominees Christopher Jackson as an imposing George Washington, Phillipa Soo as the kind-hearted wife Eliza and Jonathan Groff, who makes the most of his nine minutes as the snooty and catty King George.

Hamilton’s a fascinating human, and his journey keeps us riveted through his personal evolution and the birth of our nation. His rivalry with Burr adds a complexity – their flaws, fears, desires and regrets fuel the story. Odom has some of the show’s best songs – “Wait for It,” and “Non-Stop,” and his introduction “Talk Less” is memorable.

Featuring a score that blends hip-hop, jazz, R&B, pop and traditional Broadway show tunes, “Hamilton” is a revolutionary moment in theatre, and you won’t be able to get those songs out of your head: “My Shot,” The Story of Tonight,” “The Room Where It Happened,” “Who Lives, Who Dies, Who Tells Our Story,” “History Has Its Eyes on You” and “The World Turned Upside Down.” The Cabinet Battles are comical and thought-provoking at the same time.

The Schuyler Sisters have a sensational introduction – and Peggy (Jasmine Cephas Jones), and the songs “Helpless,” “Satisfied,” “Burn” have real depth from a female point of view. “It’s Quiet Uptown” will tug on your heartstrings.

Already, the staged musical has had profound impact on culture, politics and education, and you will see why, as Hamilton the movie transports the audience inside the Broadway show in an intimate way. (I spontaneously broke into applause a few times).

As for the ‘film’ part, we might not be in the room where it happened (Richard Rodgers Theatre) but what it lacks in the palpable energy only live theater produces, it trades for the emotions you connect with in the close-ups.

Declan Quinn’s cinematography and Jonah Moran’s editing gives us a crisp perspective. And the skill of that team — Thomas Kail’s seamless direction, Alex Lacamoire’s exquisite orchestrations and conducting, Andy Blankenbuehler’s fluid and innovative choreography and Manuel’s smart and clever words and music — are a swirling mix of craft, art and talent.

With use of steady-cam, crane and dolly, the multiple cameras create a view you would not have seen – even if you been fortunate enough in the first couple of rows. We also benefit from it being performed before a live audience – their reactions give ours some vitality. Lafayette’s line: “Immigrants – we get the job done!” produces the loudest applause.

I saw the musical once two years ago, on its first national tour at the Fox Theatre in St. Louis, and even with its cavernous 4500 seats, was gobsmacked. It was among the best theatrical experience ever – and lived up to the hype.

This view has new opportunities for discovery, to marvel at Manuel’s attention to detail and his nimble storytelling. The recurring themes and repetitive nature of the score add texture to the rhythms and harmonies, and the cast’s enunciation and verbal dexterity is remarkable.

In 2009, Miranda was invited to the White House to share what he was working on during a night of poetry-inspired entertainment. President Barack and Michelle Obama were a little taken aback by his concept – a hip-hop concert album about the founding father who is on the $10 bill. OK. Well, the rest, as they say, is history.

And Manuel has made history. An Emmy, Tony and Grammy Award winner, among his theatrical accomplishments — he wrote and starred in the Tony-winning 2008 musical “In the Heights,” was co-composer and lyricist with Tom Kitt and Amanda Green for “Bring It On!” in 2011 (produced by Mike Isaacson-led Fox Theatricals) and at Stephen Sondheim’s request, wrote Spanish dialogue and lyrics for the 2009 Broadway revival of “West Side Story.”

“Hamilton; An American Musical” opened at the Public Theatre on Jan. 20, 2015 and moved to Broadway that August. Because of the demand for tickets, he created the “Ham4Ham” lottery ($10 tickets for first couple of rows), but those who couldn’t get to Broadway or afford the sky-high ticket prices, can see the next best thing. The unforgettable theatrical experience has been made accessible for an even wider audience to appreciate.

The lighting design, by Howell Binkley (Tonys for both “Hamilton” and “Jersey Boys”), is effective on screen. Paul Tazewell’s costumes and David Korins’ deceptively simple brick-lined set designs of scaffolds, catwalks and staircases add to the show’s signature style and cohesiveness.

The film was slated for an October 2021 theatrical release, but the decision was made to stream through Disney Plus ($6.99 a month subscription or $69 for the year).

What a wonderful way to celebrate the birth of our nation and see its impact today, after a grave period of uncertainty, unprecedented pandemic and level civil unrest not seen in 50 years. It feels more urgent as a call to action, to keep this great American experiment a righteous one.

The care and skill that went into this production is obvious. “Hamilton” deserves a standing ovation in every living room across this great country of ours. The musical makes America more beautiful this Independence Day weekend.

“Hamilton” is a filmed musical directed by Thomas Kail, starring Lin-Manuel Miranda, Leslie Odom Jr., Daveed Diggs, Renee Elise Goldsberry, Phillipa Soo, Christopher Jackson and Jonathan Groff. Rated: PG-13 for language and some suggestive material, it runs 2 hours 40 minutes with 1-minute intermission. Lynn’s Grade: A Streaming on Disney Plus beginning July 3.