By Lynn Venhaus
In a towering, fearless performance, Jenny Smith embodies one of the all-time great fictional horror villains because she is so, well, normal, in “Misery.” She manages to blend neighborliness with sociopathic rage, quite a feat.
The St. Louis Actors’ Studio has invested handsomely in mounting William Goldman’s play adaptation of Stephen King’s 1987 harrowing psychological thriller, which he also worked on for Rob Reiner’s 1990 movie, “Misery.”
Smith’s terrifying Annie Wilkes, grounded in an identifiable reality, sends chills down the spine when she tells Paul, “I’m your number one fan.” But that won’t be her only phrase that will make us afraid for the author convalescing at her home.
She rescued Paul Sheldon, a successful romance novelist, from a car crash during a blizzard in rural Colorado. When he woke up, captive in her remote farmhouse, he learned she is a nurse and thought he was in safe hands. She keeps the pain pills and conversations coming in steady intervals.

Oh, those first impressions. The nightmare has only just begun. Paul will discover her manipulative, controlling ways when she reads his new book from his Misery Chastain series, and his departure manuscript that he had one copy of in his briefcase.
Revealing a dark side, Annie becomes enraged when she learns he has killed off Misery, and forces him to write a comeback novel, “Misery’s Return.” Basically, he is hostage to her whims, and typing as if his life depended on the outcome.
Goldman, two-time Oscar winner for his “All the President’s Men” and “Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid” screenplays, has kept much of the witty banter from the movie.
After artful performances as George in “Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf?” and the physically demanding role in “The Whale,” William Roth is well-suited to play a helpless patient who must shift into survival mode. Through shrewd observation and crucial timing, he must be resourceful in ways to fight back and try to escape from months-long captivity.
This is a difficult work to adapt, although it’s deceptive because of its setting — a one-act locked-room thriller between a (mostly) bedridden man and a caregiver, with a third supporting character arriving later – inquisitive Sheriff Buster (Kurt Knoedelseder in a folksy turn).
Yet director John Contini meets the challenge of conveying the growing menace, tension and maneuvers without benefit of editing or exterior locations. So much of King’s book, which is darker and more cerebral, is internal.
Contini’s cinematic use of eerie and edgy sound, which he designed, and sinister-sounding music motifs, enhance the storytelling, as does the lighting designed by Dalton Costick. Particularly effective are shadows produced in thunderstorm simulations.

St. Louis Actors’ Studio is the first regional professional theater to mount it here, and their meticulous attention to detail is admirable. The work premiered on Broadway in 2015, most notable for Laurie Metcalf’s Tony-nominated performance and Bruce Willis’ stage debut.
The play is a natural fit for the cozy Gaslight Theatre’s black box stage, but the scale of the mountainside cottage is one of the biggest challenges in STLAS’s history.
Set designer Josh Ortega and his team have fashioned a revolving three-room farmhouse that is breathtaking in scope. (At the Nov. 15 matinee performance, the audience burst into applause.) The assistant stage managers behind the scenes – Lexi Witcher and Jade Cash – rotated the rooms to reveal a kitchen and hallway.
There is an exterior door/porch drop down area for the sheriff to enter. Ortega also served as the production manager and technical director, which helped the overall aesthetic. Amy J. Page is the ever-sharp stage manager.

Kathy Bates’ unforgettable performance in the 1990 film earned her an Oscar (Fun fact: The only King character to ever win). The Annie character is one of the great human antagonists, ranked no. 17 on the American Film Institute’s list of 50 Greatest Movie Villains of All-Time (2003) – ahead of the shark in “Jaws” (18).
Smith transitions from Annie’s motherly qualities to cruelty with quicksilver mood swings, showing her deteriorating grip on reality.
Smith, who designed the appropriate character outfits and props too, fits this role like a glove. She has mastered the cadence, quirky euphemisms and eccentricities (Liberace!).
While the scenario gets grimmer, and Sheldon is forced to be more dependent, Roth must smoothly hide his mobility and getting around in the wheelchair.
And spoiler alert, anyone who has seen the movie or read the book knows what eventually happens – the hobbling, when Annie takes a sledgehammer to each ankle. (Just writing that made me wince again).
The pair’s struggles are realistically presented on stage, with fight choreography by Shaun Sheley, for the inevitable climax. Contini’s split-second blocking and the nimble performers get a workout.

With its rustic grandmotherly décor, dingy print wallpaper, vintage Royal typewriter, and practical effects in lighting and sound, St. Louis Actors’ Studio has set the stage well for collective theatrical thrills.
Chilling and claustrophobic, “Misery” earns its escape payoff, for the audience feels as cornered as the injured author throughout the 90 minutes. The material also touches on modern celebrity culture – and Annie represents the extreme, which seems more relevant today.
St. Louis Actors’ Studio presents “Misery” from Nov. 6 through 22 at the Gaslight Theatre. Performances are Thursday, Friday and Saturday evenings at 8 p.m. and on Sundays at 3 p.m. For more information or to purchase tickets, visit stlas.org or email [email protected].
Advisory: “Misery” is suitable for adult audiences and teenagers 17 and older. This Stephen King thriller features drugs, physical violence, a captive victim, and uses very strong adult language.


Lynn (Zipfel) Venhaus has had a continuous byline in St. Louis metro region publications since 1978. She writes features and news for Belleville News-Democrat and contributes to St. Louis magazine and other publications.
She is a Rotten Tomatoes-approved film critic, currently reviews films for Webster-Kirkwood Times and KTRS Radio, covers entertainment for PopLifeSTL.com and co-hosts podcast PopLifeSTL.com…Presents.
She is a member of Critics Choice Association, where she serves on the women’s and marketing committees; Alliance of Women Film Journalists; and on the board of the St. Louis Film Critics Association. She is a founding and board member of the St. Louis Theater Circle.
She is retired from teaching journalism/media as an adjunct college instructor.